HauntBound archive · catalog record
Reported phenomena — as catalogued
Built 1846–1850 by Key West's first harbor pilot, this house saw multiple Geiger children die of yellow fever and narrowly escaped demolition in 1958 — the anchor of Key West's historic preservation movement.
205 Whitehead St, Key West, FL 33040
Research updated June 2026
Age
All Ages
Cost
$$
Adults $16; students (any age) $14; children 6–12 $7.50; children under 6 free. All ticket sales final and non-refundable.
Access
Limited Access
Multi-story 19th-century home with stairs; tropical gardens are ground-level
Equipment
Photos OK
Est. 1846 · American Classic Revival Architecture · John James Audubon — 1832 Key West Visit · Key West Historic Preservation Movement · Yellow Fever Era Family History
Captain John Huling Geiger, Key West's first officially designated harbor pilot, began construction on his home at 205 Whitehead Street in 1846, after the Great Havana Hurricane had leveled much of the island. The American Classic Revival structure, built between 1846 and 1850, was designed to withstand the subtropical climate and the repeated hurricanes that struck Key West throughout the 19th century.
Geiger had married Lucretia Sanders, a woman from the Bahamas, in 1829. Together they had twelve children. The home functioned as the center of a large extended family across multiple generations. Geiger's income came from wrecking — the salvage of cargo from ships wrecked on the Florida reef — and from his role as harbor pilot guiding vessels through the hazardous reef channels. He planted the tropical garden that still surrounds the property, including what became known as the Geiger tree, a native flowering species that ornithologist John James Audubon sketched during a visit to Key West in 1832.
Several Geiger children died of yellow fever, a recurring and catastrophic disease in 19th-century Key West. One child reportedly died from a fall from a tropical almond tree growing beside the house. Four generations of the family occupied the home for nearly 110 years.
The last resident was Captain William Bradford Smith, Geiger's great-grandson, who lived in the house alone for over 25 years following the deaths of other family members. Without plumbing or electricity, he occupied the deteriorating structure until his death in 1956. By 1958 the city had condemned the building and planned demolition to make way for a gas station. Mitchell Wolfson, a Key West native and media executive, purchased the property and invested $250,000 in its restoration. The Audubon House Museum and Tropical Gardens opened in 1960 and is credited as the catalyst for Key West's broader historic preservation movement.
Sources
The Audubon House's paranormal reputation is anchored in the layered losses of the Geiger family: children taken by yellow fever, a young one who fell and died in the garden, and the long solitary decline of William Bradford Smith, who spent 25 years in a house without plumbing as the last of his line.
Captain Geiger himself has been reported on the second-floor balcony and in the tropical gardens — a large man described as watchful rather than malevolent. Paranormal theorists have connected this figure to a persistent local legend that he buried a portion of his wrecking wealth somewhere on the property. The apparition has been described by multiple visitors as simply standing and observing.
The daughter Hannah's portrait is the most unusual of the site's paranormal reports. Museum staff documented so many accounts of visitors experiencing acute sadness — sometimes to the point of tears — while viewing it that the painting was moved from the main gallery to an isolated section of the house. Disembodied voices and the sounds of children laughing and speaking have been reported in various rooms, attributed by paranormal investigators to the yellow-fever-era deaths of Geiger's children.
William Bradford Smith, the last resident, has generated his own reports. An EVP (electronic voice phenomenon) recording purporting to be his voice was captured during a paranormal investigation in his former bedroom on the second floor.
Notable Entities
Tour the restored home of Captain John Huling Geiger — Key West's first harbor pilot — containing period antiques and a significant collection of original John James Audubon prints. The surrounding tropical garden, planted by Geiger himself, features the native Geiger tree that Audubon sketched during his 1832 Key West visit. Open Monday through Sunday, 9:30 a.m. to 4:15 p.m.; closed Christmas Day and New Year's Day.
Some links on this page may earn HauntBound a small commission when you book, at no extra cost to you. Our editorial picks are independent. Full disclosure
This Key West tour includes Audubon House and Tropical Gardens on its route.
Book this tourThis Key West tour includes Audubon House and Tropical Gardens on its route.
Book this tourEvery HauntBound history is researched from documented sources. We clearly separate verified historical fact from paranormal folklore.
Free Guide
11 verified stops, rated for families, mapped in order. Free.
One email to confirm, then the guide link. Unsubscribe anytime.
Key West, FL
Fire Station No. 3 at 1024 Grinnell Street opened in 1907 as one of Florida's oldest firehouses and operated for 91 years before closing in 1998. Its most notorious figure is Joseph 'Bum' Farto — a career firefighter who rose to fire chief in 1964, was convicted of selling cocaine and marijuana to an undercover officer in February 1976, and disappeared days later while out on bail.
Key West, FL
The Custom House was completed in 1891 to consolidate Key West's federal functions — customs operations, the post office, and the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Florida. Designed by Supervising Architect William Freret in the Richardsonian Romanesque style, the building processed hearings connected to the USS Maine disaster of 1898. The Navy occupied it from the 1930s through the 1970s, after which it sat vacant and deteriorating for nearly two decades. The Key West Art & Historical Society acquired the building and undertook a nine-year, $9 million restoration, reopening it as a museum in 1999.
Key West, FL
The current Key West Lighthouse, opened in 1848, was built to replace the original tower destroyed in the Great Havana Hurricane of October 1846. That storm killed dozens of Key West residents and claimed eight people who sought refuge in or near the original lighthouse. The site's subsequent history includes an unusual run of keeper deaths: in 1889, keeper John Carroll died of typhoid in the quarters; his wife Mary Armanda Fletcher assumed the post and died of the same illness three months later.