Self-Guided Visit
Visit Midnight Mary's grave
Locate the pink-granite Hart monument and read the unusual full-narrative inscription that has fueled local legend for over 150 years.
- Duration:
- 30 min
Photo coming soon
Cemetery / Burial Ground
Evergreen Cemetery (Midnight Mary's Grave)
Historic 1872 New Haven cemetery whose most famous monument — the pink granite grave of Mary E. Hart — carries an unsettling Job 34:20 epitaph that local lore has reread as a curse since the late 19th century.
769 Ella T. Grasso Boulevard, New Haven, CT 06519
Wheelchair Accessible
Research-Backed · 4sources
Age
All Ages
Cost
Free
Free to visit during posted cemetery hours.
Access
Wheelchair OK
Paved drives with grass shoulders.
Equipment
Photos OK
Est. 1872 · Historic west-New Haven cemetery, active since the mid-19th century · Mary E. Hart monument with unusual narrative inscription (1872) · Cataloged in Yale University's Yale Inscriptions project
Evergreen Cemetery occupies a long parcel on what is now Ella T. Grasso Boulevard on the west side of New Haven. By 1872 it was already an active burial ground used by middle-class New Haven families. Mary E. Hart — by surviving family accounts likely a seamstress — was born December 16, 1824 and lived an otherwise unremarkable New Haven life. On October 15, 1872, at approximately noon, she collapsed suddenly while preparing for her day's work. She remained unconscious until her death later the same day, and was buried in Evergreen.
Her monument is a pink granite stone unusual for its narrative inscription, which reads in part: 'At high noon, just from, and about to renew her daily work, in her full strength of body and mind, Mary E. Hart, having fallen prostrate, remained unconscious, until she died at midnight.' Beneath the biographical text is an abridged passage from Job 34:20: 'The people shall be troubled at midnight and pass away.' The combination of the precise hour of death and the somber biblical citation is what gave the grave its enduring local fame.
The Evergreen Cemetery Association continues to operate the grounds as an active cemetery, and the Hart monument remains in its original location. The grave is documented in the Yale University 'Yale Inscriptions' project, which catalogs notable New Haven epitaphs.
Sources
- https://campuspress.yale.edu/yaleinscriptions/2024/11/10/midnight-mary/
- https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/11149432/mary_e-hart
- http://newenglandfolklore.blogspot.com/2015/06/the-ghost-of-midnight-mary.html
- https://www.damnedct.com/midnight-mary-new-haven/
'Vanishing hitchhiker' apparition reported near Winthrop AvenueLocal tradition of misfortune befalling those who disturb the grave at midnight
According to folklore documented by Damned Connecticut, the New England Folklore blog, and Yale Inscriptions, two related legends attach to Mary E. Hart's monument. The first claims that Hart's sudden collapse was misdiagnosed as death — possibly a stroke or catalepsy that mimicked death in a pre-modern medical era — and that she was buried alive. A version of the tale says her family, troubled by a dream in which she pleaded for help, exhumed the coffin and found evidence she had revived in the grave. The Yale Inscriptions project notes this 'premature burial' motif is a recurring 19th-century folkloric pattern and is not supported by contemporary newspaper accounts.
The second strain, recounted by New England Folklore, casts Hart as a vanishing hitchhiker: her ghost is said to be encountered along Winthrop Avenue at night, sometimes asking for a ride to her former home, and disappearing before the destination. Both strands of lore reframe the Job 34:20 inscription as a curse — local tradition warns that disturbing the grave after midnight invites misfortune or sudden death.
The Hart grave is a regular stop on New Haven's ghost walks. No reported phenomena tied to the grave have been documented in newspaper reporting; the lore is folkloric, oral, and tour-guide tradition.
Notable Entities
Mary E. Hart ('Midnight Mary')
Media Appearances
- Our New England Legends Podcast 221 — Midnight Mary in Evergreen Cemetery
- Jeff Belanger podcast — Midnight Mary in Evergreen Cemetery
Plan Your Visit
1 way to experienceSources & Further Reading
Every HauntBound history is researched from documented sources. We clearly separate verified historical fact from paranormal folklore.
Similar Destinations
Cemetery / Burial Ground
Grove Street Cemetery
New Haven, CT
Grove Street Cemetery was organized in 1796 as the New Haven Burying Ground and incorporated in October 1797, the first chartered private nonprofit cemetery in the United States. Its 1845 Egyptian Revival brownstone gateway, designed by New Haven architect Henry Austin and carved by Hezekiah Augur, is a leading example of the style in America. The cemetery was designated a National Historic Landmark in 2000.
$ All Ages
Family: High
Cemetery / Burial Ground
Union Cemetery
Easton, CT
Union Cemetery sits at the intersection of Sport Hill and Stepney roads in Easton, Connecticut, adjacent to the Easton Baptist Church. The earliest recorded burial is that of Ebenezer Hubbell in 1761; the cemetery served as a communal graveyard for several local Protestant congregations before formal incorporation as the Union Cemetery Association in 1902.
$ All Ages
Family: High
Cemetery / Burial Ground
Oakwood Cemetery
Syracuse, NY
Oakwood Cemetery was dedicated in November 1859 and designed by Howard Daniels, a New York City landscape gardener whose picturesque plan made Oakwood one of the most notable examples of the American rural cemetery movement. Adjacent to what would become Syracuse University, the 160-acre cemetery is the last of Daniels' fifteen rural cemetery designs and remains an active burial ground today.
$ All Ages
Family: High
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Evergreen Cemetery (Midnight Mary's Grave) family-friendly?
Quiet active cemetery; the 'buried alive' premise of the legend may unsettle very young visitors but is appropriate for older children with context. Overall family fit: Moderate.
How much does it cost to visit Evergreen Cemetery (Midnight Mary's Grave)?
Free to visit during posted cemetery hours. This location is free to visit.
Do I need to book in advance?
No advance booking is required, but checking availability is recommended.
Is Evergreen Cemetery (Midnight Mary's Grave) wheelchair accessible?
Yes, Evergreen Cemetery (Midnight Mary's Grave) is wheelchair accessible. Terrain: Paved drives with grass shoulders..