Historic Hartsel Cafe at the Geographic Heart of Colorado
Hartsel, Colorado, Hartsel, CO 80449
Age
All Ages
Cost
$$
Standard cafe and saloon pricing. The Highline operates as a working cafe in Hartsel, Park County's small geographic-center community.
Access
Wheelchair OK
Single-story rural cafe building
Equipment
Photos OK
Hartsel sits at the geographic center of Colorado in Park County, in the high-altitude South Park basin. The town was founded in 1880, named for early rancher Samuel Hartsel, and developed as a small ranching and stagecoach community. The building that now houses the Highline Cafe and Saloon dates to the early 20th century and is among the older surviving commercial structures in town.
The building's early operating history included a stretch as an ice cream parlor during the early 1900s. In subsequent decades the space passed through multiple cafe operators, most recently the Mountain Muffin Restaurant before being reopened under the current Highline Cafe and Saloon ownership. The building anchors Hartsel's small main street and serves both local Park County ranching customers and the through-traffic on US Route 24 and Highway 9 crossing the South Park basin.
Detailed construction-history records for the building, including original owner, builder, and exact construction date, are not surfaced in mainstream Park County historical materials and would require local archival research at the Park County Local History Archives in Fairplay.
Sources
The Mountain Muffin and Highline lore in Park County folklore is light. Local accounts describe a recurring 20th-century report of small electrical and mechanical anomalies in the cafe space: lights cycling on and off, coffee makers turning themselves on, and the cash register drawer opening without source. These reports are typical of small American restaurant lore in older commercial buildings.
The folklore attributes the phenomena to a historic hanging in the building's back room, in which a man is said to have killed another man over a love-triangle dispute and then taken his own life. The specific identification of names, dates, and circumstances varies between retellings and is not corroborated in primary Park County newspaper or law-enforcement records accessible to general research. The framing here treats the historical claim as folkloric oral tradition.
Local accounts indicate that visible activity dropped off in the years before the current Highline Cafe operation, with the most recent significant reports dating back roughly 18 years from the Shadowlands compilation date. The building continues to operate as a working cafe at the heart of Hartsel.
Stop at the Highline Cafe and Saloon in Hartsel, Colorado, an early-1900s commercial building that once operated as an ice cream parlor and later as the Mountain Muffin Restaurant. The building anchors Hartsel's small downtown at the geographic center of the state.
Every HauntBound history is researched from documented sources. We clearly separate verified historical fact from paranormal folklore.
Florissant, CO
The building at 2679 US Hwy 24 in Florissant was constructed in 1886 and served as the private residence of James Castello and his wife Catherine Hughes Castello. James died in the home. Catherine died from burns after her dress caught fire. At least two of their children — Frank's son and daughter — also died in Florissant as young children. The building has operated as the Costello Coffee House for many years.
Black Hawk, CO
The building at 111 Main Street in Black Hawk dates to 1896, built by Julius Kline on the site of Black Hawk's first schoolhouse. The structure served various functions — school, hotel, rooming house — across the 19th and 20th centuries before reopening as a casino in 1992 following Colorado's legalization of limited-stakes gaming. Its Mine Shaft Bar in the basement was a local landmark across multiple ownership eras.
Denver, CO
Larimer Street in Denver is the city's oldest commercial block. The building at 1433 Larimer, in what is now Larimer Square, served as a speakeasy during the Prohibition era (1920-1933). Josephina's Restaurant operated at this address from 1974 until its closure roughly thirty years later. The space was subsequently divided between Rioja and Corridor 44, a champagne bar that opened in 2005.