A 1923 Fort Collins landmark where a bellhop apparition and phantom piano music recur on the upper floors
259 S. College Ave., Fort Collins, CO 80524
Research updated June 2026
Age
All Ages
Cost
$$
Hotel room rates vary by season; check website for current pricing.
Access
Wheelchair OK
Flat urban hotel with elevator access
Equipment
Photos OK
Fort Collins landmark since 1923 · U.S. Army barracks during World War II · Prohibition-era Old Town commercial district
The Armstrong Hotel opened in 1923 on South College Avenue, one year after Prohibition had made the sale of alcohol illegal nationwide. Fort Collins' Old Town district was then a lively commercial center with a documented bootlegging trade operating beneath its respectable surface, and the hotel occupied a prime position in that environment.
During World War II, the U.S. Army requisitioned the Armstrong to house military personnel, a common wartime conversion for large buildings near transportation corridors. The hotel returned to civilian use after 1945 and has operated as a lodging property continuously since. In 2023 the hotel marked its centennial with programming documenting its hundred years on South College Avenue.
The building's exterior and interior retain period character consistent with a 1920s commercial hotel. It appears in the Thomas Kingsley Troupe's 2013 review of haunted Colorado hotels, which places the Armstrong alongside better-known properties such as the Stanley and the Boulderado in the state's documented ghost-hotel tradition.
Sources
The Armstrong Hotel's paranormal tradition centers on two phenomena that appear independently across multiple accounts. The first is auditory: guests report hearing soft piano music in the hallways late at night when no instrument is in use, with the sound fading when someone walks toward it. The second is visual and physical: a bellhop figure has been reported in the corridor near Room 210, and investigators visiting that room have documented objects moving without contact.
The Thomas Kingsley Troupe's 2013 Colorado haunted hotel survey, which draws on direct interviews with staff, places the Armstrong's bellhop tradition alongside more widely publicized Colorado hotel hauntings. Room 210 is identified as the primary focal point in that account.
No historical record pinning the bellhop to a specific deceased employee has been located in current sources. The Prohibition-era and WWII history of the building provides plausible period anchors for the lore, but the connection between the specific history and the specific apparition is not documented — the bellhop tradition appears to have developed through guest experience rather than archival research.
Book a room at the Armstrong for a historic Old Town Fort Collins stay. Room 210 is particularly associated with paranormal reports, including witnesses documenting objects moving without apparent cause. Guests report soft piano music drifting through the corridors at night.
Every HauntBound history is researched from documented sources. We clearly separate verified historical fact from paranormal folklore.
Leadville, CO
The Delaware Hotel was built in 1886 during Leadville's silver boom. On March 14, 1899, Mary Coffey was shot in the spine by her husband Jerry as she fled down a staircase; she died from her injuries days later. The hotel is documented in Roger Pretti's published book 'Lost Between Heaven and Leadville' and has been associated with sightings of Horace Tabor and Doc Holliday.
Crested Butte, CO
The Forest Queen Hotel opened in 1881 on Elk Avenue in Crested Butte, then a coal and silver mining town. The building operated as a brothel in its early years before transitioning to general hotel use. It remains one of the oldest continuously operating hotels in Colorado.
Cripple Creek, CO
Built in 1896 after the fire that destroyed most of Cripple Creek, the Imperial Hotel opened as the Collins Hotel and became a centerpiece of the mining town's post-fire recovery. In the early 20th century it was managed by George Long, an English immigrant who ran the property with his wife and raised their children there.