HauntBound archive · catalog record
Reported phenomena — as catalogued
Crested Butte's 1881 Main Street hotel markets itself as Colorado's most haunted, anchored by the story of a woman called Elizabeth
129 Elk Ave, Crested Butte, CO 81224
Research updated June 2026
Age
All Ages
Cost
$
Economy hotel; room rates typically under $150/night
Access
Limited Access
Two-story 19th-century wood-frame building; stairs to upper rooms
Equipment
Photos OK
Est. 1881 · One of Colorado's oldest continuously operating hotels · Crested Butte mining era
Crested Butte was platted in 1880 as a railroad terminus and mining supply town for the coal mines and silver claims of Gunnison County. The building at 129 Elk Avenue was operating as a brothel by 1881, one of several establishments of that type on what was then the commercial and entertainment center of the district.
As the mining economy contracted and Crested Butte's character shifted—first to a quiet ranching community, then to a ski town after the Crested Butte Mountain Resort opened in 1961—the building on Elk Avenue transitioned to general hotel use. It has operated continuously since 1881, which the hotel describes as making it Colorado's longest-running hotel operation.
The building is a two-story wood-frame structure that retains much of its original character. The Coal Creek Grill operates on the ground floor. The hotel markets its paranormal history prominently, including a website statement declaring it 'Colorado's Most Haunted Hotel Since 1881' and a policy prohibiting Ouija boards 'for the comfort of other guests.'
Sources
The story of Elizabeth has circulated in Crested Butte since at least the early 20th century. According to local accounts, in 1884 a woman who went by Liz fell in love with a gambler who was passing through town. She gave him her savings. He took them next door to the Kochevars Saloon—still operating on Elk Avenue—won substantially at cards, and left Crested Butte without her.
The precise details of what followed are unclear in primary sources, but the account that has been repeated consistently is that Elizabeth died after going through the second-story window of Room 4 into Coal Creek below. The hotel does not give a cause of death in its marketing materials, and the 1884 timeframe predates systematic Colorado vital records. The story is treated as local oral history rather than documented fact.
Room 4 is the focal point of reported paranormal activity. Multiple guests across different visits and decades have described a persistent weight on the chest during sleep in that room, an unwelcoming sensation distinct from the other rooms. Doors in the building slam without a proximate cause, and kitchen staff report pots and pans moving in the Coal Creek Grill. A Discovery Channel television crew investigated the property and documented accounts from guests and staff.
Notable Entities
Media Appearances
Economy rooms in the 1881 building on Elk Avenue, Crested Butte's main street. Room 4 on the second floor is identified as the most active location in paranormal accounts. The hotel prohibits Ouija boards for the comfort of other guests.
Every HauntBound history is researched from documented sources. We clearly separate verified historical fact from paranormal folklore.
Durango, CO
The Jarvis Suite Hotel opened in 1888 as a residential and commercial building in downtown Durango, Colorado, built during the silver-era growth that transformed the city along the Denver and Rio Grande narrow-gauge railway corridor. The building has operated continuously and is among the older surviving commercial structures on the downtown grid.
Durango, CO
Cleveland pharmacist Henry Strater built his namesake hotel in Durango in 1887 at a cost of $70,000, envisioning it as a destination for travelers on the Denver and Rio Grande Railway. The hotel went bankrupt in 1895 following the silver panic, was acquired by a consortium of Durango businessmen in 1926, and was designated a National Register of Historic Places charter member in 1989.
Aspen, CO
Jerome B. Wheeler, then co-owner of Macy's department store, built the Hotel Jerome in 1889 at a cost of approximately $150,000. It was one of the first buildings west of the Mississippi with full electric lighting, and it became the social hub of Aspen's silver boom. The hotel declined with Aspen after the 1893 silver crash but survived as the town's only operating hotel, managed for decades by former bartender Mansor Elisha.