Est. 1887 · Whittier History · Quaker Settlement History · Victorian Architecture · Local History Museum
The Whittier Historical Society was founded to preserve the history of a city established in the 1880s primarily by Quaker settlers from the Midwest. Whittier, named for the Quaker poet John Greenleaf Whittier, grew quickly after its founding as a planned community, developing a commercial district and residential neighborhoods that reflected its founders' values and cultural background.
The museum has operated since 1983 in the Bailey House at 6755 Newlin Ave, a Victorian-era structure built specifically for Frank and Lula Bailey. The building's age and architectural character — high ceilings, darkened wood, artifacts of lives lived a century ago — have made it a natural candidate for ghost tour programming.
For years, Whittier residents circulated accounts of unexplained occurrences in the building. Staff described objects appearing to move, cold areas with no drafts, and the sense of being observed while alone in the galleries. These accounts remained informal until Jacob Caputo, founder of Haunted Whittier, partnered with the museum to develop a structured ghost tour program. The Whittier Historical Society collaborated on the program as a way to engage new audiences with the museum's collection. Tours sold out quickly and have become a recurring seasonal offering.
Sources
- https://whittiermuseum.org/
- https://hollyweirdparanormal.blubrry.net/2023/12/29/ep-124-haunted-whittier-minisode-interview-haunting-at-the-whittier-historical-society-musuem/
Moving objectsCold spotsUnexplained whispersPhantom presence
The reported phenomena at the Whittier Museum follow a pattern common to old buildings with dense collections of personal artifacts: the sense that objects are not quite where they were left, temperature variations without drafts, sounds in empty rooms. Staff who work in the building regularly have described these occurrences over multiple years, lending some consistency to accounts that might otherwise be dismissed as visitor novelty.
A podcast episode from Hollyweird Paranormal, recorded in December 2023, includes an interview with someone associated with the museum's haunting tradition, documenting accounts of voices heard in specific gallery areas and movement in peripheral vision when staff are alone in the building after hours. The episode also covers an investigation conducted on-site.
Jacob Caputo's Haunted Whittier tour frames the phenomena as the presence of former Whittier residents with emotional attachments to the artifacts displayed in the museum's collections — items that were once part of daily life in 19th and early 20th century Whittier. This interpretation, while not scientifically verifiable, is the organizing narrative for the tour program and shapes how visitor experiences are collected and reported.
Media Appearances
- Haunted Whittier Minisode — Whittier Historical Society Museum (Podcast, 2023)