Private Lake Community's Lady of the Lake
29033 Lake Vista Dr, Agoura Hills, CA 91301
Age
All Ages
Cost
Free
The Malibou Lake area is accessible via public roads and overlooks. The lake and island are within a private residential community (Malibou Lake Mountain Club) not open to the public without member or resident invitation.
Access
Limited Access
Mountain terrain; public road access only; no lake-level public access
Equipment
Photos OK
Est. 1922 · Private Mountain Community · Santa Monica Mountains History
Malibou Lake was developed in 1922 as a private residential and recreational retreat in the Santa Monica Mountains, roughly 30 miles west of downtown Los Angeles near present-day Agoura Hills. The Malibou Lake Mountain Club owns and manages the 350-acre property, which includes custom homes, ranch houses, and cabins set around a private lake.
The community developed its character in the early-to-mid 20th century as a retreat for Los Angeles residents seeking mountain and lake access. The modest scale — approximately 250 residents — has kept the community close-knit. Membership and lake access are restricted to residents and their guests.
The small island at the center of the lake gave the community one of its distinctive landmarks. It has no formal name in public records.
Sources
Margaret Hersh Robertson spent decades as a resident of the Malibou Lake community, where she developed the habit of swimming out to the lake's small island each morning. The practice was well known to other residents — a visible, regular part of the community's daily life.
Robertson died in 1993 at age 85. Following her death, accounts began to emerge from lake residents describing a figure seen swimming in the lake, just below the surface, wearing a bathing cap. One account places the sighting alongside a couple in a canoe — the figure swimming beside them before they realized no one should be in the water at that hour.
The accounts attribute her continued presence to the deeply habitual nature of the swim. The lake was, by all reports, a central fact of Robertson's daily life for most of a century. The figure described — below the surface, in a bathing cap, moving with purpose toward the island — matches precisely the practice she performed in life.
No formal investigation of the claims has been published. The accounts come from residents of a private community not generally accessible to outside observers.
Notable Entities
Malibu Lake and its small central island are accessible by view from public roads and the Malibu Lake Overlook hiking trail in the Santa Monica Mountains. The lake itself is within the private Malibou Lake Mountain Club, a members-only residential community operating since 1922. No public lake or island access without an invitation from a resident.
Every HauntBound history is researched from documented sources. We clearly separate verified historical fact from paranormal folklore.
Elizabeth Lake, CA
Elizabeth Lake is a natural perennial sag pond that sits directly on the San Andreas Fault in the Sierra Pelona Mountains of northwestern Los Angeles County at 3,228 feet elevation. The lake was known to Spanish settlers as Laguna del Diablo. Beginning in the 1830s, ranchers established properties on its shores but repeatedly abandoned them, attributing their losses to a creature living in the lake.
Palmdale, CA
Una Lake is a small sag pond in the San Andreas Rift Zone of the Antelope Valley, immediately east of Lake Palmdale along Sierra Highway in Los Angeles County. The lake was separated from the larger original water body in the 1870s when Southern Pacific constructed a raised causeway across the lake bed. The South Antelope Valley Irrigation Company stabilized the pond as a year-round water source in 1897. The property is fenced and patrolled by private security.
Hollywood, CA
Laurel Canyon Boulevard and Lookout Mountain Avenue in the Hollywood Hills have intersected horse-drawn traffic and automobile traffic since the road was cut through the hills in the early 20th century. The winding canyon corridor became a primary route from the Hollywood flatlands to the ridge communities above.