The accounts attached to the Live Oak evolved over time, as documented by two separate individuals writing in different years.
The owner at the time of the original documentation described the ghost as a really nice girl, even shy — someone customers encountered and reported positively. Her behavior was specific and low-intensity: she flushed toilets near closing time, consistently and repeatedly. It was the kind of behavior that registers only because of its regularity.
By 2004, a bartender who had worked the location for nearly a year reported a change: Michelle had stopped flushing and started ringing the food bell in the kitchen constantly, at all hours of the day and night. The behavioral shift — from a single repetitive action to a different repetitive action — is unusual in reported haunting accounts, which tend to describe fixed phenomena.
The same bartender described seeing Michelle's shadow in peripheral vision when alone in the building, and noted that one of the cook's sons appeared to converse with the ghost regularly, though the cook's son was unwilling to confirm the identity of who he was speaking to.
A second figure — a man in black who walks through the space — is mentioned in the 2004 account separately from Michelle, without backstory or identification.
A paranormal investigation group published a corrective examination of the legend, establishing that key biographical details in the original account were inaccurate. Their research did not address the reported phenomena, only the historical record surrounding the murder.