HauntBound archive · catalog record
Reported phenomena, as catalogued
+ 2 further entries on record
Buffalo Bill's Wild West Headquarters Hotel
856 Broadway St, Sheridan, WY 82801
Research updated October 2026
Age
All Ages
Cost
$$$
Overnight rates vary by season; Open Range is currently closed for dining experiences.
Access
Wheelchair OK
Paved sidewalks; historic building with elevator access to most floors
Equipment
Photos OK
Est. 1893 · National Register of Historic Places · Buffalo Bill Cody Connection · Wild West Show Headquarters · National Historic Landmark · Railroad Era Architecture · Wyoming Statehood Era
Modeled on a Scottish hunting lodge by architect Thomas Kimball, the Sheridan Inn opened on May 27, 1893, just one year before Wyoming's railroad branch reached the town. The three-story frame structure with its sweeping front porch and 69 dormer windows was built by the Sheridan Land Company to anchor a young cow town aspiring to permanence. When Buffalo Bill Cody first arrived, he became a part owner and made the Inn his Northern Plains base of operations.
From that long porch, Cody auditioned new performers for his Wild West Show, evaluating ropers, sharpshooters, and bronc riders against the silhouette of the Bighorn Mountains. The Inn served as a stop for cattle barons, mining magnates, and traveling dignitaries through the late 19th and early 20th centuries. Calamity Jane is recorded as a frequent visitor, as were Ernest Hemingway, Will Rogers, and various American presidents.
In 1901, a 22-year-old Virginian named Catherine B. Arnold arrived to work at the Inn. Known to all as Miss Kate, she remained on staff for 64 years, serving in turn as seamstress, desk clerk, hostess, housekeeper, and de facto babysitter for traveling families. Flowers cut from her garden behind the building decorated the dining room tables every day she worked. When she died in 1968, her stated final wish was to be interred within the building she had called home for over six decades. Her ashes were placed inside the wall of her third-floor room.
The Inn faced demolition in the 1960s but was rescued through a community preservation effort and is listed on the National Register of Historic Places. After a major restoration, it reopened as a 22-room boutique hotel with rooms themed around Buffalo Bill and figures from his life. The Inn is owned and operated as the Sheridan Inn, BW Signature Collection, and continues to host overnight guests and weddings; Open Range is currently closed for dining experiences.
Sources
Miss Kate Arnold's continued presence at the Sheridan Inn is reported with a casualness that suggests long acquaintance. Staff describe her behavior as proprietary rather than alarming. Doors close behind guests in empty hallways. Lamps switch on without prompting. The temperature in her third-floor room drops noticeably even on warm summer evenings, a phenomenon documented by multiple visiting investigators.
Miss Kate's room is the only quarters in the Inn whose interior wall contains a person. Her cremated remains were placed there at her request when she died in 1968, after 64 years of continuous service. The room is bookable. Guests who request it report variations on the same experiences: footsteps in an empty hallway, the quiet click of a doorknob turning, a soft sense of being chaperoned.
The Wyoming Historical Society has documented several first-hand accounts from staff. One former employee described arriving for an early morning shift to find a third-floor lamp burning in a room that had not been rented the night before. Another reported the smell of cut flowers in the dining room hours before the kitchen opened. Miss Kate was known in life for the bouquets she cut from her own garden each morning.
While the Sheridan Inn does not market itself as a haunted attraction, the legend of Miss Kate is an open secret among staff and longtime guests. Investigators have visited and recorded their findings; the management neither encourages nor denies the activity. The Inn presents Miss Kate the way she presented herself in life: quietly competent, attentive to the building's needs, present without being obtrusive.
Notable Entities
Book one of 22 guest rooms, each themed around Buffalo Bill Cody and figures from his Wild West Show. Miss Kate's third-floor room, where her ashes are interred in the wall, is the most-requested for guests hoping to encounter the Inn's resident steward.
Open Range is currently closed for dining experiences. In the restaurant, staff and diners have reported the resident presence of Miss Kate Arnold opening doors and turning lights on and off near the dining room she once decorated with garden flowers.
Some links on this page may earn HauntBound a small commission when you book, at no extra cost to you. Our editorial picks are independent. Full disclosure
See current room rates and availability at Sheridan Inn.
Check rates and bookRates come from booking partners, so a small property may not be listed. Book direct with Sheridan Inn
Every HauntBound history is researched from documented sources. We clearly separate verified historical fact from paranormal folklore.
Free Guide
9 verified stops, rated for families, mapped in order. Free.
One email to confirm, then the guide link. Unsubscribe anytime.
Austin, TX
Colonel Jesse Lincoln Driskill, a Tennessee-born cattle baron who supplied beef to the Confederate Army and later the Texas Rangers, opened The Driskill Hotel on December 20, 1886. Its first event, two weeks after opening, was the inaugural ball for Texas Governor Sul Ross. Driskill sold the hotel in 1888 after severe drought devastated his cattle herds and died in 1890. The hotel has hosted every Texas governor's inaugural ball since 1887.
Kewaunee, WI
The Hotel Karsten opened on Valentine's Day 1913 in Kewaunee, Wisconsin, replacing an earlier wood inn called The Steamboat House that burned in the early 1910s. Built and operated by William Karsten Sr., the 52-room Arts and Crafts hotel sits on the Lake Michigan shoreline and remains one of the few surviving hotels of its period in the region.
Gettysburg, PA
Built around 1810 by tanner John F. McFarlane and expanded with an 1833 brick addition, the Farnsworth House sits on Baltimore Street in Gettysburg. During the 1863 battle, Confederate sharpshooters occupied the structure, and the south-facing wall still carries more than 100 bullet holes from Union counter-fire.