Mukwonago's Neighborhood Tavern with a Restless Upstairs
215 N Rochester St, Mukwonago, WI 53149
Age
All Ages
Cost
$$
American comfort food and scratch kitchen; typical bar and restaurant pricing.
Access
Limited Access
Historic building with stairs to upper floors
Equipment
Photos OK
The building on North Rochester Street in Mukwonago, Wisconsin has served as a neighborhood gathering place since its days as a tavern. For many years it operated under the name Inn the Olden Days, accumulating decades of local community history and, according to former owners and staff, an accumulation of unexplained activity.
A fatal fire in an upstairs apartment is documented in local records: authorities responded in the early morning hours of March 23rd and found Julie McKenzie, age 39, dead in the apartment bathroom after the fire was extinguished. The circumstances of the fire established a specific tragic event in the building's history that subsequent occupants have associated with the anomalous activity reported on the upper floors and in the basement.
The building is now operated as Fork in the Road, a scratch-kitchen American bistro that ranks among the highest-rated restaurants in Mukwonago, with a 4.5 rating on TripAdvisor and the top position among the area's 34 restaurants. Current operations do not market the haunted history, but the building's reputation in local paranormal circles has been documented by the Paranormal Investigators of Milwaukee.
Sources
The paranormal accounts from this building emerge from the people who worked and lived in it, not from outside investigators. Former owners of the Inn the Olden Days period described the upstairs apartments as the most active area: cupboards found open with no explanation, a condition that repeated regardless of how carefully they had been secured.
Waiters working in the dining room reported finding salt and pepper shakers on the floor, sometimes at distances from their tables that required more than gravity to explain. The shakers were never observed in motion — they were simply found displaced.
The basement produced the most consistent staff reports, though the specific nature of those accounts was not detailed in available sources. Basement reports at former tavern buildings in the upper Midwest are common enough that they constitute their own regional tradition.
The Paranormal Investigators of Milwaukee formally investigated the building and documented their findings, lending more structure to the informal staff reports that preceded their involvement.
Dine at Mukwonago's top-rated restaurant, housed in a building with a history as a tavern, a site of a fatal upstairs fire, and reports of unexplained cupboard openings, salt shakers flying off tables, and basement activity. The building operated for decades as 'Inn the Olden Days' before being renamed.
Every HauntBound history is researched from documented sources. We clearly separate verified historical fact from paranormal folklore.
Lambertville, NJ
The building at 74 South Union Street in Lambertville was constructed in the early 1860s as the home of William McCreedy, who also operated McCreedy's Paper Mill across the street. It was converted to an inn and tavern in the early 1900s. In 1993, Doreen and Melissa Masset renamed it the Inn of the Hawke. The property endured the catastrophic 1903 Lambertville flood, which destroyed the original covered bridge. The Inn of the Hawke closed in March 2022 after 29 years; The Hawke steakhouse opened at the same location.
Boscobel, WI
The Central House — now known as the Hotel Boscobel — was built in 1865 in Boscobel, Wisconsin by Prussian-born entrepreneur Adam Bobel, who constructed the original two-story limestone structure with a business partner for $5,000. A three-story extension was added in 1873. Fire gutted the building on January 7, 1881, but Bobel rebuilt; the hotel reopened by May 13 of the same year. Adam Bobel managed the property until his death in 1885. In 1898, two traveling salesmen sharing Room 19 conceived the idea that became the Gideons International, one of the world's largest Bible distribution organizations. The building is listed on both the State and National Registers of Historic Places.
Baraboo, WI
The Old Baraboo Inn was built as a boarding house in 1864 directly across from the Baraboo railroad depot. Over a century and a half it served as a honky-tonk bar, a brothel, and a roadhouse said in local accounts to have hosted Prohibition-era figures including Al Capone. It now operates as a bar and grill at 135 Walnut Street and hosts regular ghost-hunt events.