Glenbeulah is a small community in Sheboygan County, Wisconsin, and its cemetery reflects the burial patterns of early Wisconsin settlement. The oldest graves date to the early 1800s, installed when the surrounding land was still being broken for agriculture and the population was scattered across townships that lacked formal municipal infrastructure.
The cemetery sits at the end of a footpath through woodland, concealed enough from the road that it can be missed by those not specifically looking. Its remoteness, combined with reports of vandalism and alleged Satanic ritual activity in prior decades, led local authorities to enforce visiting hours strictly.
Among the graves is that of Grace Baumann, who died five days after her birth in 1943. The grave has become a community memorial point — visitors leave toys, stuffed animals, and small offerings, a practice that has persisted for decades. A figure seen near a large tree at the edge of the cemetery, described as a small child watching the grounds, has been associated with Grace by those who report the apparition.
The cemetery was featured on an episode of Unsolved Mysteries — reportedly the segment in which investigators documented what they characterized as evidence of paranormal activity — though the specific episode details have not been confirmed in available archives.
Sources
- https://www.wisconsinfrights.com/glenbeulah-cemetery/
- https://www.onlyinyourstate.com/experiences/wisconsin/glenbeulah-cemetery-wi
ApparitionsOrbsResidual hauntingPhantom sounds
The cemetery's reputation rests on a cluster of specific, independently described phenomena rather than a single dramatic event.
The glowing grave is the most frequently cited. Visitors report a grave marker that emits light — not reflected moonlight or phosphorescence from organic material, but a distinct luminescence that persists under observation. The specific grave is identified in lore but not by name in available sources.
A second grave bears a different distinction: a pair of shoes, visible on or near the stone, that appear without explanation and have been reported on multiple occasions by different visitors.
A man is said to have hanged himself in the cemetery, and his figure — described as walking among the graves after midnight — is part of the site's established legend. Suicide within a cemetery was historically notable; many church traditions prohibited burial of suicides in consecrated ground, which gives the story an additional layer of institutional complexity.
The most emotionally specific account centers on Grace Baumann's grave. Visitors who leave offerings there have described the sensation of a child's presence nearby, and some report seeing a small figure watching from beside a large tree at the cemetery's perimeter.
Unsolved Mysteries reportedly featured the cemetery in an episode in which investigators captured what they described as genuine paranormal evidence. Paranormal researchers from Chad Lewis's organization have conducted documented investigations of the site.
Notable Entities
Grace BaumannHanged Man
