Est. 1834 · Galveston's oldest burial ground (established 1834) · Yellow fever epidemic burials (1839, 1867) · 1900 hurricane casualties · Elize Roemer Alberti murder case (1894)
The Old City Cemetery predates the city of Galveston's 1839 incorporation, having been established in 1834 to serve the growing settlement on the barrier island. When Galveston was formally organized in 1839, the Galveston City Company donated land adjacent to the original cemetery, expanding it into the broader Broadway Cemetery complex that would eventually span seven distinct burial grounds over six city blocks.
Yellow fever was the cemetery's first major catastrophe. An 1839 outbreak killed 250 Galvestonians. The 1867 epidemic killed 725. Between epidemics, the cemetery received the dead from the ordinary hazards of a major 19th-century port: maritime accidents, fires, and violence. Bodies were buried in the sandy soil, and as the city repeatedly raised its grade elevation throughout the twentieth century, new interments were placed above earlier graves. Some sections of the Old City Cemetery contain burials three bodies deep, with approximately 1,200 visible markers representing a substantially larger number of actual interments.
The September 8, 1900 hurricane killed between 6,000 and 8,000 Galvestonians — still the deadliest natural disaster in American history. The Old City Cemetery received some of the identified dead; the adjacent Evergreen Cemetery absorbed the largest single expansion, with approximately 900 burials added in the immediate aftermath.
The cemetery's most documented individual burial is Elize Roemer Alberti. On December 4, 1894, Alberti poisoned wine with morphine and gave it to four of her children — Willie (age 4), Dora, Ella, and Lizzie. Two children, Emma and Wilhelmina, survived. Alberti, whom Galveston newspapers called 'the demented mother,' was convicted and sent to an asylum in San Antonio. After her release she returned to Galveston and died by suicide. She was buried in the same family plot as the four children she killed — one of the few recorded instances of a perpetrator interred with their victims.
Sources
- https://ghostcitytours.com/galveston/haunted-galveston/old-city-cemetery/
- https://www.txgalveston.org/cemetery/cemocity.htm
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Broadway_Cemetery_Historic_District
- https://texashillcountry.com/old-city-cemetery-haunted-spirits/
ApparitionsCold spotsPhantom soundsGeneral unease
The Old City Cemetery's paranormal reputation rests primarily on the weight of its documented history rather than on any single dramatic incident. Nearly two centuries of epidemic burials, storm casualties, and the unusual Alberti interment have made it a standard stop on every Galveston ghost-tour circuit.
Ghost City Tours, which rates its Haunted Cemetery Tour 4.9 stars across hundreds of reviews, centers the Old City Cemetery's narrative on Elize Roemer Alberti. Her burial in the same plot as the four children she poisoned in 1894 is the most specific story: investigators and tour participants describe an unease around the Alberti section that they attribute to the unique circumstances of the burial arrangement. The cemetery's ghost-tour accounts note that, unlike some sites, there are no well-documented historical reports of specific apparitions; the site's status comes from the accumulated documented human tragedy and from reports collected by tour participants over many years.
The three-deep burial structure, created by twentieth-century grade raises, means that in some sections the ground surface sits several feet above the original coffins. Tour guides note this as context for activity that seems to occur at locations with no visible marker — the graves below may have no headstone at the current grade level.
Notable Entities
Elize Roemer Alberti (alleged)