Est. 1882 · 19th Century Commercial Architecture · Paranormal Investigation Site
Milo and Clara Arnold built the Knickerbocker Hotel on West Erie Street in Linesville in the early 1880s. The building opened to the public on January 12, 1882 and combined four functions under one roof: hotel rooms upstairs, a restaurant on the ground floor, an entertainment lounge, and a private residence for the Arnold family.
Clara Arnold, the co-owner, died of tuberculosis just three years after the building opened. She was 37. She is the most-named historical figure in the hotel's surviving folklore. The Arnold family continued to operate the property for some years after her death.
The Knickerbocker passed through later ownership and remains a free-standing brick three-story structure in central Linesville. In recent decades the building has been used principally as a paranormal investigation venue rather than as a working hotel. The property has been featured on A&E's Paranormal State, the Bio Channel's My Ghost Story, and the program Resident Undead, and it has been investigated by Keystone Paranormal, Oil Region Paranormal, and the Penn State Paranormal Research Society. It was included in the World's Largest Ghost Hunt programs in 2018 and 2019.
A published skeptical investigation by an investigator from the Skeptical Inquirer concluded that the investigator did not personally observe activity but enjoyed the company of the owner and the historical context of the building. The current operation hosts ticketed investigation events through third-party organizers and offers VIP tours led by an investigator and a medium.
Sources
- https://www.knickerbockerlinesville.com/about-us/about.html
- https://skepticalinquirer.org/exclusive/investigating-ghosts-at-the-knickerbocker-hotel/
- https://www.panicd.com/knickerbocker-hotel-pa.html
- https://www.wytv.com/news/local-news/exploring-the-haunted-histories-of-the-knickerbocker-sprucevale/
ApparitionsShadow figuresEVPEMF anomaliesPhantom footstepsPhantom sounds
The Knickerbocker is one of the more thoroughly investigated buildings in western Pennsylvania. Its body of folklore began with Clara Arnold's death and has accumulated over the four decades that paranormal teams have been working in the building.
The most-named entity is Clara herself, observed in upstairs rooms and on the staircase. Other reported figures include a child, a phantom cat, and unidentified shadow figures in the basement and along the second-floor corridor. Reports across multiple investigations describe footsteps overhead in empty rooms, knocks responsive to investigator questions, and brief flashlight responses on K2 meters.
A Skeptical Inquirer investigator who visited the property documented a thorough investigation in which no anomalies presented themselves to him personally. He praised the building, its owner, and the integrity of the operation, and noted that the absence of activity on his particular night did not falsify the broader pattern of reports. The hotel hosts a live webcam directed at one of its more active reported areas, allowing remote viewers to watch in real time.
The building was featured in the Ghost Detectives 2015 episode produced for paranormal cable programming and has been the subject of documentaries and YouTube investigation series. The Arnold-era furnishings, the era-appropriate brick exterior, and the relatively undisturbed interior layout make the property a useful subject for investigators interested in nineteenth-century commercial buildings, regardless of one's interpretation of the reported phenomena.
Notable Entities
Clara ArnoldChild EntityPhantom Cat
Media Appearances
- A&E Paranormal State
- Bio Channel My Ghost Story
- Resident Undead
- Ghost Detectives (2015)