HauntBound archive · catalog record
Reported phenomena, as catalogued
1852 National Historic Landmark Theater on a Colonial Jail Site
12 N Prince St, Lancaster, PA 17603
Research updated September 2026
Age
All Ages
Cost
$$$
Show ticket prices vary by production. Box office: 717-397-7425.
Access
Wheelchair OK
Paved downtown sidewalks, ADA-accessible entrance
Equipment
No Photos
Est. 1852 · National Historic Landmark · Conestoga Massacre Site · Regional Theater · American Theater History
The current Fulton Theatre was built in 1852 on the foundation of Lancaster's former jail, which dated to 1739. The site carries one of the most documented atrocities in colonial Pennsylvania history. In December 1763, fourteen Conestoga were murdered by a settler mob known as the Paxton Boys; the twenty surviving members of the Conestoga were placed in protective custody at the Lancaster jail. On December 27, 1763, thirteen days after the first massacre, the Paxton Boys broke past the sheriff and others defending the jail and killed all of the remaining Conestoga.
The theater itself opened in 1852 and quickly became a regional touring stop. Its stage hosted Mark Twain, Sarah Bernhardt, and silent-film performer Marie Cahill in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. The building was designated a National Historic Landmark in 1964 and is one of two theaters in the United States carrying that designation.
The Fulton operates today as a class B regional theater under the League of Regional Theatres. It produces a year-round Mainstage season of musicals, plays, and family programming. The theater has been featured on Discovery+'s Portals to Hell and is a stop on the Haunted Lancaster Ghost Tour.
Sources
The Fulton's haunted reputation has accumulated over more than a century of working theater operation. The building was investigated by the Discovery+ paranormal series Portals to Hell, which filmed an episode at the theater that aired in 2021.
The most-cited resident spirit is the Woman in White, identified in theater folklore as Marie Cahill, a silent-film and stage performer who appeared at the Fulton in the early 1900s. Staff and actors have reported the apparition of a woman in pale period dress in the upper boxes and on the catwalks. Sarah Bernhardt is also part of the building's lore, though attributions to specific performers vary across accounts.
Reports include phantom applause heard from empty house seats, the upright piano in the rehearsal hall playing without a performer present, and unexplained sounds in the catwalks. Some accounts describe screams attributed to the Conestoga who were killed in the 1763 jail whose foundation still supports the building. These reports are framed in local folklore as a residual presence rather than an interactive haunting.
The Lancaster Ghost Tour operated by US Ghost Adventures stops at the Fulton's exterior and recounts the building's layered history. The theater itself does not market overnight investigations; access to the building's haunted reputation is best had through a performance or a docent-led pre-show tour.
Notable Entities
Media Appearances
Catch a Mainstage production in a working 1852 theater built atop the foundation of Lancaster's colonial jail. Productions span musicals, classics, and contemporary plays. Pre- and post-show docent tours of the building's history are sometimes offered.
US Ghost Adventures' Haunted Lancaster walking tour passes the Fulton's exterior and recounts the building's history, including the 1763 Conestoga massacre on the jail site beneath the theater and the resident folklore of the Woman in White.
Some links on this page may earn HauntBound a small commission when you book, at no extra cost to you. Our editorial picks are independent. Full disclosure
This Lancaster tour includes Fulton Opera House on its route.
Every HauntBound history is researched from documented sources. We clearly separate verified historical fact from paranormal folklore.
Free Guide
11 verified stops, rated for families, mapped in order. Free.
One email to confirm, then the guide link. Unsubscribe anytime.
Atlanta, GA
The Fox Theatre opened on Christmas Day 1929 as a movie palace originally designed as the Yaarab Shrine Temple. The 4,665-seat venue at 660 Peachtree Street NE was designed by Olivier J. Vinour of the firm Marye, Alger and Vinour in a lavish Moorish and Egyptian Revival style. It was designated a National Historic Landmark on May 11, 1976 and operates today as a major concert and touring-show venue.
Cincinnati, OH
Cincinnati Music Hall at 1241 Elm Street opened in 1878, designed in the High Victorian Gothic style. It was built on land that had served as the city's potter's field — a burial ground for the indigent, disease victims, and unidentified dead — used from the 1820s until the cemetery closed around 1857. Bones have been discovered beneath the building in 1927, 1988, and again during the 2016-2017 renovation. The building was designated a National Historic Landmark in 1975.
Cripple Creek, CO
The Butte Theater on Bennett Avenue is a historic Cripple Creek opera house rebuilt after the April 1896 fires that devastated the city. Associated with the Imperial Casino, it has operated as a performance venue for more than a century and is reportedly haunted by a ghost named Jack, linked to the nearby fire department.