Dinner
Dinner at Mistress Suzanne's
Dine in the restaurant inside the original 1812 inn, named for Joe Rider's third wife Suzanne and serving as the inn's primary public-facing space.
- Duration:
- 1.5 hr
Photo coming soon
Haunted Hotel / Inn
Rider's Inn
1812 Painesville Stagecoach Inn With a Long Tradition of Hauntings
792 Mentor Avenue, Painesville, OH 44077
Age
All Ages for restaurant; 18+ for overnight stays at owner's discretion
Cost
$$
Restaurant and B&B pricing per published rates.
Access
Limited Access
Multi-story 1812 building with stairs
Equipment
Photos OK
Est. 1812 · One of the oldest continuously operating inns in northeastern Ohio · Documented Underground Railroad stop · Operated as a speakeasy during Prohibition
Rider's Inn was built in 1812 by Joseph Rider on what was then a developing stagecoach route across northern Ohio. The inn opened during the War of 1812, with Joseph Rider building it specifically to provide soldiers and travelers a place to eat, drink, and sleep along the route. Painesville sat on a key east-west corridor that would later be designated US Route 20.
In the decades before the Civil War, the inn was associated with the Underground Railroad, with local accounts placing it on a route used by people escaping slavery as they moved toward Lake Erie and the Canadian border. The inn also operated as a speakeasy during the Prohibition era of the 1920s, capitalizing on its established hospitality footprint.
Joseph Rider's third wife, Suzanne, served as hostess at the inn during his ownership. Local tradition holds that Suzanne died at the inn under circumstances that were not fully explained, and her name is now attached to the inn's restaurant (Mistress Suzanne's) and to Room Eleven, her former living quarters.
The inn has remained in continuous operation since 1812 under successive owners, and is generally cited as one of the oldest operating inns in northeastern Ohio.
Sources
- https://www.ridersinns.com/
- https://wandercuse.com/discover-riders-inn-a-haunted-hotel-in-ohio/
- https://www.onlyinyourstate.com/stays/ohio/haunted-pub-cle
- https://creepycleveland.net/2008/01/05/melonheads-and-riders-inn/
Welcoming female presence in Room ElevenOccasional movement of small personal itemsFootsteps in upstairs hallwaysApparition associated with a Civil War-era soldier near the front windows
Rider's Inn has the unusual distinction of a ghost tradition that is welcoming rather than threatening. The most-told story involves Suzanne, Joseph Rider's third wife, who served as hostess at the inn and lived in what is now Room Eleven. Local tradition holds that Suzanne occasionally answered the door for late-arriving guests in her nightgown while the owners were away, and that this hospitable role has continued in ghost form.
Guests overnighting in Room Eleven report a sense of being watched over rather than disturbed, occasional movement of small personal items, and faint footsteps in the hallway outside. Restaurant staff have, over the inn's long modern operation, described what they interpret as a Civil War-era soldier near the front windows, occasionally seen waving toward the road.
The inn embraces its haunted heritage and incorporates it into its marketing without commercializing it into a programmed attraction. Reports collected over its modern bed-and-breakfast operation are consistent enough that local paranormal investigators treat the inn as a stable, well-attested example of a hospitality-themed historic haunting.
Notable Entities
Suzanne Rider (third wife of Joseph Rider)
Plan Your Visit
2 ways to experience Overnight Stay
Overnight bed and breakfast
Stay in one of the historic guest rooms. Room Eleven, associated with the inn's longest-running ghost tradition, is the most commonly requested.
- Duration:
- 12 hr
Sources & Further Reading
Every HauntBound history is researched from documented sources. We clearly separate verified historical fact from paranormal folklore.
Similar Destinations
Haunted Hotel / Inn
Buxton Inn
Granville, OH
The Buxton Inn in Granville, Ohio was built in 1812 by Orrin Granger and operated as a tavern and post office for early westward travelers. Major Horton Buxton purchased it in 1865 and operated it until his death in 1934. Opera singer Ethel 'Bonnie' Bounell ran the inn from 1934 until her death in Room 9 in 1960. Preservationists Orville and Audrey Orr rescued the building in 1972 and expanded it. The inn was sold in March 2026 to New England Development Company and continues operating as a hotel.
$$$ All Ages
Family: Moderate
Haunted Hotel / Inn
Golden Lamb
Lebanon, OH
The Golden Lamb in Lebanon, Ohio has operated continuously since 1803, making it Ohio's oldest business. Founded by Jonas Seaman as a stagecoach stop, the inn grew through the 19th century into a four-story landmark that hosted twelve U.S. presidents, Charles Dickens, and Harriet Beecher Stowe. In 2026, the property celebrates 100 years of family ownership.
$$$ All Ages
Family: High
Haunted Hotel / Inn
Lumber Baron Inn & Gardens
Denver, CO
The Lumber Baron Inn is a Scottish immigrant-built 1890 Victorian mansion in Denver's Potter-Highlands neighborhood. Originally home to John Mouat, a lumber mill owner, the property later fell to disrepair and was divided into apartments. On October 13, 1970, two young women — Cara Lee Knoche, 17, and Marianne Weaver, 18 — were found murdered in what is now the Valentine Suite. Both cases remain open cold cases.
$$$ All Ages
Family: Low
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Rider's Inn family-friendly?
Family-friendly restaurant; overnight ghost-tradition rooms may be too suggestive for younger children. Historic stairs limit accessibility. Overall family fit: Moderate.
How much does it cost to visit Rider's Inn?
Restaurant and B&B pricing per published rates.
Do I need to book in advance?
Yes, reservations are required.
Is Rider's Inn wheelchair accessible?
Rider's Inn has limited wheelchair accessibility. Terrain: Multi-story 1812 building with stairs.