1918 Beaux-Arts hotel on Public Square — site of Eliot Ness's 1938 Torso Murders interrogation and a fourth floor of unexplained plumbing and door activity.
24 Public Square, Cleveland, OH 44113
Age
All Ages
Cost
$$$
Standard rates start near $200/night for a downtown Cleveland boutique hotel; varies by season and event.
Access
Wheelchair OK
Fully accessible modern hotel inside a historic Beaux-Arts shell; elevators throughout
Equipment
Photos OK
Est. 1918 · Public Square Landmark · Cleveland Torso Murders History · Beaux-Arts Architecture · Van Sweringen Brothers Development
The lot at the southwest corner of Public Square has been associated with continuous lodging operations dating to Mowry's Tavern, established in 1814. Mowry's was succeeded by the Forest City House, a mid-19th-century hotel demolished in 1916 to make way for the present building. The new Hotel Cleveland opened on December 16, 1918, built at a cost of $4.5 million by the Van Sweringen brothers as part of their Terminal Tower development.
Designed by Graham, Anderson, Probst & White of Chicago, the hotel originally offered 1,000 rooms across a Beaux-Arts limestone exterior. The Van Sweringens later integrated the hotel with the Terminal Tower complex, making it directly accessible from Cleveland Union Terminal when that complex opened in 1930. The hotel was renamed at multiple points in its history, including the Sheraton Cleveland and Stouffer's Cleveland Inn, and operated as the Renaissance Cleveland Hotel for several decades.
The most-cited historical anchor in the hotel's haunted lore is the 1938 interrogation of Dr. Francis Edward Sweeney, the primary suspect in the Cleveland Torso Murders, an unsolved serial killing case attributed to a perpetrator known as the 'Mad Butcher of Kingsbury Run.' Safety Director Eliot Ness oversaw Sweeney's confinement and questioning at the hotel for approximately two weeks in May 1938; Sweeney failed two polygraph tests administered by Leonarde Keeler but was never charged. He voluntarily committed himself to a veterans hospital shortly afterward.
Following a major restoration completed in 2023, the property reopened as Hotel Cleveland, Autograph Collection within the Marriott family of brands.
Sources
According to Cleveland Vintage and OnlyInYourState's coverage of haunted Cleveland hotels, paranormal reports at the property are unusually concentrated on the fourth floor. Guests and staff have described toilets flushing on their own, faucets switching on and off, slamming or self-opening doors, lights cycling without an obvious source, and figures glimpsed entering rooms that turn out to be vacant.
Local lore offers two explanatory threads. One ties the activity to construction workers who may have died during the 1916-1918 build of the hotel, although no roster of confirmed fatalities specific to this construction project has been independently documented in public sources. The other thread links the manifestations to patrons or staff of Mowry's Tavern, the Forest City House, and other 19th-century inns that occupied the same Public Square lot before the present hotel was built.
The hotel also features prominently in Cleveland's true-crime tradition because of Eliot Ness's documented 1938 interrogation of Torso Murders suspect Dr. Francis Sweeney on the premises. While Sweeney's confinement and questioning are well-attested in newspaper records and police-museum holdings, they are not directly linked to specific apparitional reports at the hotel; the connection is invoked atmospherically by ghost-tour operators rather than as a documented sighting.
Ghost-tour stops at the hotel typically remain on the lobby level out of respect for guests; activity is recounted as described by hotel staff over the years rather than experienced live by tour groups.
Notable Entities
Media Appearances
Book a room at the restored 1918 Beaux-Arts hotel on Public Square. The fourth floor is the floor most often cited in haunted-hotel reports; the property does not market itself as haunted but staff and guests have discussed activity in regional press.
Hotel Cleveland is a recurring stop on Cleveland ghost tours that recount the 1938 Eliot Ness interrogation of Torso Murders suspect Dr. Francis Sweeney and the long-running fourth-floor lore.
Every HauntBound history is researched from documented sources. We clearly separate verified historical fact from paranormal folklore.
Chattanooga, TN
Terminal Station, designed by New York architect Donn Barber and opened in 1909, was Chattanooga's main railroad passenger depot for six decades. After passenger rail service ended in 1970 the building was converted in 1973 to the Chattanooga Choo-Choo Hilton and Entertainment Complex, named for the 1941 Glenn Miller song. The property was added to the National Register of Historic Places in 1973 and underwent a 2023 renovation of the hotel building (renamed The Hotel Chalet) under Trestle Studio.
Phoenix, AZ
Hotel San Carlos opened on March 20, 1928, as a seven-story, 175-room downtown Phoenix hotel and quickly became a stop for Hollywood's Golden Age — Clark Gable, Carole Lombard, Mae West, Gene Autry, and Marilyn Monroe among them. The building stands on the site of Phoenix's first school, the 1874 Little Adobe, and remains in continuous operation as a boutique hotel.
Safety Harbor, FL
The Safety Harbor Resort & Spa sits on the western shore of Tampa Bay above the natural Espiritu Santo Springs. Captain James F. Tucker built a sanatorium on the site in 1920, which Dr. Salem Baranoff expanded in the mid-twentieth century into a renowned mineral-springs spa. The property is a member of Historic Hotels of America.