HauntBound archive · catalog record
Reported phenomena — as catalogued
Newark's founding 1666 Presbyterian congregation, whose 1787 Georgian sanctuary and adjacent burying ground anchor folklore amplified by the 2005 discovery of two intact 'Newark mummies' cast-iron coffins displaced from the congregation's former cemetery.
820 Broad Street, Newark, NJ 07102
Research updated May 2026
Age
All Ages
Cost
Free
Free to visit during posted hours and worship services.
Access
Wheelchair OK
Sidewalk-level access at the Four Corners; interior steps to the sanctuary.
Equipment
Photos OK
Est. 1787 · Founding 1666 congregation of Newark · Listed on the National Register of Historic Places (November 2, 1972) · Anchor of the Four Corners Historic District · Source congregation for the 2005 'Newark mummies' discovery
First Presbyterian Church was organized in 1666 alongside the founding of Newark by Puritan settlers from Connecticut led by Robert Treat. It is the city's oldest continuously active congregation. The current building at 820 Broad Street, in what is now the Four Corners Historic District, was completed in 1787 by architect Eleazer Ball in a Georgian Colonial style featuring a 204-foot steeple.
The church and its adjacent burying ground were added to the New Jersey Register of Historic Places on August 2, 1972, and to the National Register of Historic Places on November 2, 1972. Notable burials in the surviving graveyard include William Burnet (1730-1791, Continental Congress delegate), U.S. Representative Silas Condit (1778-1861), and U.S. Representative Thomas Ward (1759-1842).
In 2005, during construction of the Prudential Center hockey arena a few blocks south on the site of the church's former Mulberry Street cemetery, forensic archaeologist Scott Warnasch and his team uncovered two intact cast-iron Fisk Metallic Burial Cases. One contained the remains of Captain William A. Pollard (died September 5, 1854). The other belonged to Mary Camp Roberts (died May 26, 1852, age 88). Both were members of the First Presbyterian congregation, whose Mulberry Street burial ground had been displaced when its land was sold in the 19th century. The discoveries received extensive coverage in New Jersey Monthly and Weird NJ and became known as the 'Newark mummies.'
Sources
Newark ghost-tour narratives circulated by US Ghost Adventures treat the burying ground at 820 Broad Street as a focal point for unresolved congregational dead. According to these accounts, when the church's former Mulberry Street cemetery was sold in the 19th century, not all bodies were properly relocated, and the surviving Old First grounds inherited the spiritual unfinished business of the displaced.
This folklore intensified after 2005, when excavation for the Prudential Center hockey arena exposed two unbroken cast-iron Fisk Metallic Burial Cases from the former Mulberry Street site. Forensic archaeologist Scott Warnasch identified one as Captain William A. Pollard (died September 5, 1854) by the engraved nameplate; the other, after extensive investigation, as Mary Camp Roberts (died May 26, 1852, age 88). Both were members of the First Presbyterian congregation. Coverage in New Jersey Monthly, Weird NJ, and the Jerusalem Post repeatedly framed the find as 'Newark's mummies,' and a subsequent string of injuries to the New Jersey Devils hockey team produced years of half-serious 'are the mummies cursed?' coverage.
First-person ghost reports at Old First itself are limited in published sources; the legend's strength comes from the documented displacement history and the visceral image of intact 19th-century bodies surfacing under a modern arena.
Notable Entities
Media Appearances
Visit the 1787 Georgian Colonial sanctuary with its 204-foot steeple in Newark's Four Corners Historic District, then walk the burying ground containing burials of 18th and 19th century Newark notables including U.S. Representatives Silas Condit and Thomas Ward.
Some links on this page may earn HauntBound a small commission when you book, at no extra cost to you. Our editorial picks are independent. Full disclosure
Every HauntBound history is researched from documented sources. We clearly separate verified historical fact from paranormal folklore.
Free Guide
12 verified stops, rated for families, mapped in order. Free.
One email to confirm, then the guide link. Unsubscribe anytime.
Galena, IL
Galena, Illinois was one of the wealthiest river towns of the antebellum Upper Mississippi, anchored by lead mining and Civil War-era political prominence — eight Galena residents served as Union generals, including Ulysses S. Grant. The Haunted Galena Tour Company has run guided ghost walks through this preserved 19th-century downtown for more than two decades.
Richmond, VA
St. John's Episcopal Church is Richmond's oldest church, established in 1741 on land donated by city founder William Byrd II. It is most famous as the site where Patrick Henry delivered his 'Give me liberty, or give me death' speech at the Second Virginia Convention on March 23, 1775. The surrounding churchyard contains notable burials including U.S. Declaration of Independence signer George Wythe and Elizabeth Arnold Poe, mother of Edgar Allan Poe.
Newark, NJ
The current Newark Broad Street Station was designed by Frank J. Niles and built 1901-1903 by the Delaware, Lackawanna & Western Railroad as part of a grade-separation project. It replaced an 1873 depot on the same site and is the successor to the original 1836 Morris & Essex depot. The station was added to the National Register of Historic Places in June 1984 and remains an active NJ Transit hub serving the Morristown Line, Gladstone Branch, and Montclair-Boonton Line.