Laurel Grove Cemetery

The most consistently reported sighting at Laurel Grove involves a woman in white robes seen near the main entrance gates after the cemetery closes. Witnesses describe the figure as peaceful, neither threatening nor communicative — she appears, stands, and is gone. The sightings have drawn enough attention over the years to be discussed on New York radio station WOR, and dozens of people have reported observing the figure through the main gates from Totowa Road after dusk.

The adjacent roadway carries a second, separate legend. Totowa Road along the eastern edge of the cemetery runs between the grounds and the Passaic River, with a sharp bend that locals call Dead Man's Curve. The Annie legend holds that a teenage girl was walking home from prom in the 1960s when she was struck by a vehicle on this curve. Her ghost has been reported walking the road, and a tradition holds that her father returns to the guardrail on the anniversary of her death to repaint it red.

The Annie legend has multiple versions in circulation. Some accounts place her burial in the Van Dyck mausoleum inside Laurel Grove itself. No newspaper documentation of the specific accident has been publicly identified, though the Weird NJ archives and America's Haunted Roadtrip have collected extensive witness accounts of both the road and gate sightings.

The white-robed woman at the gates and Annie on the road are treated by locals as distinct phenomena — the cemetery ghost is calm and interior-facing, while Annie is associated with the road itself.