Cape May's Most Haunted Historic Beachfront Hotel
727 Beach Ave, Cape May, NJ 08204
Age
16 years and older
Cost
$$$
Hotel room rates vary by season; Cape May peak season is summer. Check hotelmacomber.com for current pricing.
Access
Limited Access
Historic building with stairs; Victorian-era construction without elevator
Equipment
Photos OK
Est. 1916 · Cape May Historic Architecture · New Jersey Hospitality History
Cape May is the oldest seaside resort in the United States, its Victorian architecture largely preserved through a series of historical designation decisions that began in the 1970s. The Hotel Macomber, open since 1916, predates many of those designations and has its own unbroken operating history.
Sarah Davis built the hotel and served as its owner through the difficult decades of the 1920s and 1930s. In the 1920s, her young daughter Cannell contracted encephalitis from a mosquito bite and died. The disease's transmission mechanism was well understood by then, but treatment options were limited. Cannell was a child when she died.
Sarah Davis died by suicide inside the hotel in the 1930s. The timing is generally placed after her daughter's death, though the relationship between the two events is a matter of family history rather than documented record. The hotel continued operating after her death.
The building is the last historic landmark structure erected in Cape May during the Victorian era according to local accounts. It sits steps from the beach on Beach Avenue and has accumulated more than a century of guest history within its walls. The hotel has been described in New Jersey paranormal circles as the state's most haunted hotel.
Sources
Room 10 is where the most documented accounts originate. Irene Wright visited the Hotel Macomber for years, always requesting the same room, developing a close relationship with the previous owner's child. After her death, the accounts from Room 10 began: televisions switching on without input, lights activating and extinguishing, objects moved from where guests left them. The activity is consistently described as stronger when children are present in the room.
The kitchen tells a different story. A former employee — a woman, according to the accounts — choked to death on food while working in the building. Her presence is described as occupying the kitchen area generally and concentrating in the walk-in storage room. The accounts involve sound rather than visual apparitions.
The basement has its own resident. Named the Growler by those familiar with the hotel's reputation, this presence is distinguished by auditory phenomena: groaning, knocking, and sounds that suggest someone engaged in a building project. Paranormal investigators who have visited the hotel have reported experiences including chandelier movement, cold rooms, and physical vibrations.
The historical tragedies of the building — Sarah Davis's suicide, the death of her daughter Cannell — are rarely cited in the active haunting accounts, which instead center on the kitchen employee and Irene Wright. This disconnect between the most dramatic historical facts and the most reported phenomena is itself a peculiarity of the Macomber's reputation.
Notable Entities
Book Room 10 - where longtime 1940s guest Irene Wright (known as the Trunk Lady) is most frequently reported - or request a room near the kitchen, where a former employee who choked to death is said to remain active in the walk-in storage area. The hotel operates seasonally (May through October) and is steps from the Cape May beach.
Every HauntBound history is researched from documented sources. We clearly separate verified historical fact from paranormal folklore.
Cape May, NJ
The Inn at 22 Jackson occupies an 1880s Victorian mansion in Cape May, New Jersey's historic seaside resort district. The building served as a private residence before its conversion to a bed and breakfast at 22 Jackson Street, half a block from the beach. Local accounts suggest the property had a prior history as a bordello and gambling parlour before the conversion.
Bay Head, NJ
The Grenville Hotel in Bay Head, New Jersey was constructed in 1890 on land purchased by Anna Nunemaker in 1886, with the building erected by Wycoff Applegate and his wife Susan. Several of the Applegate children died young, an event the building's paranormal tradition connects to reports of children's laughter in the corridors. The property changed hands multiple times before the Spurgat family purchased it in 1956; Harry and Renee Typaldos have owned it since 2003.
Genoa, WI
Big River Inn dates to either 1879 or 1896 (sources vary) in Genoa, Wisconsin. The building originally functioned as a restaurant before evolving into a combined inn and restaurant. It now operates as Water View Inn, maintaining its paranormal reputation while serving contemporary hospitality functions.