Small early-twentieth-century impoundment off Shades of Death Road in Allamuchy Township, named for the wraith-like mist that rises from its surface on cool mornings
Allamuchy Township, NJ 07820
Research updated May 2026
Age
All Ages
Cost
Free
Free; located in Allamuchy Mountain State Park
Access
Limited Access
Rough rural road, narrow shoulders, no formal trailhead at the lake. Allamuchy Mountain State Park trails are unpaved.
Equipment
Photos OK
Est. 1900 · Allamuchy Mountain State Park · Featured in Weird NJ folklore documentation · Subject of 2013 SyFy 'Haunted Highway' segment
Ghost Lake was created in the early twentieth century when two wealthy local landowners dammed a creek that ran through the narrow valley between houses they had recently built. According to Weird NJ's archival research, the men named the lake after the wraith-like mist that frequently rose from the surface in cool morning air, and named the surrounding pass 'Haunted Hollow.' The lake is not labeled on USGS topographic maps but appears in state park documentation.
Shades of Death Road (Warren County Route 619) runs approximately 6.7 miles through Liberty, Independence, and Allamuchy townships. The road's unusual name is documented from at least the nineteenth century, with the most-supported explanation tracing it to a malaria outbreak around 1850 in which mosquitoes bred in the surrounding swamps caused repeated illness and death in the Great Meadows area. Alternative folk etymologies — that the road was named for shaded tree canopies and later renamed after violent incidents — have been popularized but lack definitive primary-source documentation.
The area gained a reputation for criminal activity in the 1920s and 1930s. Court and newspaper records document at least three murders along or near the road during that period: a man beaten to death with a tire jack during a robbery, a woman who killed and dismembered her husband, and the unsolved shooting of local resident Bill Cummins, whose body was found in a mud pile. The corridor's modern folklore reputation owes much to Weird NJ magazine, which featured the road and lake repeatedly in the 1990s and 2000s, and to a 2013 SyFy 'Haunted Highway' segment.
Sources
Local tradition recorded by Weird NJ holds that the early-twentieth-century landowners named the lake after the white mist that frequently rises from its surface in cool morning air — a meteorologically routine phenomenon at small impoundments in wooded valleys. Within that mist, hikers and drivers along Shades of Death Road have reported seeing figures, both human and indistinct.
A secondary tradition, repeated in the original Shadowlands account, asserts that the lake was constructed over a Native American burial ground. According to Lenape historians consulted by Weird NJ, the area is part of the historical Lenape (Munsee) homeland, and pre-contact archaeological sites are documented in Warren County more broadly. However, no specific burial ground beneath the present Ghost Lake site has been authenticated in the public record. Visitors should treat this claim as folklore rather than verified history.
Other reports include the sound of running footsteps on the road shoulder at night, the smell of decay in still air, and figures seen briefly in headlights that are not there on a second pass.
Media Appearances
Daytime self-guided drive along Shades of Death Road (Warren County Route 619), with views of Ghost Lake just south of the Interstate 80 overpass. Park only at designated state park areas; the surrounding land is a mix of state forest and private property. Visit during daylight hours — the road is narrow, twisting, and patrolled at night.
Every HauntBound history is researched from documented sources. We clearly separate verified historical fact from paranormal folklore.
West Milford, NJ
Clinton Road is a roughly 10-mile rural road in West Milford, Passaic County, running from Route 23 near Newfoundland north to Upper Greenwood Lake through dense, undeveloped woodland. Its eerie reputation dates back over a century to when the area was called the 'five mile woods.' Landmarks include the ruins of Cross Castle, the 1905 Tudor stone mansion of English-born railroad banker Richard James Cross, demolished by Newark's water department in 1988.
Mendham, NJ
Combs Hollow Road runs through Morris County in Mendham Township, New Jersey, a rural area of heavily wooded hills traversed by narrow two-lane roads with sharp bends. The road's bridge became the focus of a regional ghost legend tied to a hit-and-run fatality, though no independent historical record of the specific incident has been located.
Aerial survey · USDA NAIPCass City, MI
Crawford Road runs through a rural stretch of Tuscola County southeast of Cass City in Michigan's Thumb. The bridge that once carried the road over a small creek or drain near the Cass River has since been removed, leaving only a dirt road crossing roughly 100-200 feet south of Kelly Road. The location's notoriety comes entirely from a 19th-century folk legend rather than a documented historical event.