A stretch of US Highway 87 between Great Falls and Fort Benton where drivers report a Native American man who steps into the road, is struck with a thump, then vanishes without a trace or a dent.
US Highway 87 near Black Horse Lake, Great Falls, MT 59401
Age
All Ages
Cost
Free
Free public highway; the legend is experienced as a drive-by along US Highway 87 northeast of Great Falls.
Access
Limited Access
Open prairie highway with no pull-offs at the lake bed; high-speed two-lane road with limited shoulder.
Equipment
Photos OK
Black Horse Lake sits in Cascade County, Montana, a short distance northeast of Great Falls and roughly three miles southeast of the Benton Lake National Wildlife Refuge. It is a seasonal lake of about 576 acres that is usually dry, filling only during spring snowmelt and early-summer rains. The lake gives its name to the surrounding stretch of open prairie that US Highway 87 crosses on its way from Great Falls to Fort Benton.
This corridor is one of the older travel routes across north-central Montana, connecting the Great Falls area with the historic Missouri River port of Fort Benton. The road runs through flat, sparsely populated grassland with long sight lines, few structures, and minimal lighting, conditions that make night driving here disorienting and that have helped a roadside ghost story take hold and spread.
The legend has been documented by Montana regional outlets and travel publications including OnlyInYourState, Distinctly Montana, and Great Falls radio station The River 97.9. These sources treat the story as folklore rather than verified history, and note that no specific fatal accident at this spot has ever been confirmed in the public record. The lake and highway themselves are entirely real and easy to locate; it is the hitchhiker that resists documentation.
Sources
The phantom hitchhiker of Black Horse Lake is among the most widely retold road legends in Montana. According to accounts collected by OnlyInYourState and Distinctly Montana, motorists driving the lonely stretch of US Highway 87 northeast of Great Falls describe seeing a lone man with long black hair, often said to be Native American, walking along the shoulder with his thumb out as if seeking a ride.
The encounter follows a consistent pattern. As the vehicle draws close, the figure suddenly rolls over the hood and across the windshield with a heavy thump, exactly as a real person struck by a car would. The driver, certain they have hit someone, pulls over and gets out, only to find no body, no injured man, and not so much as a scratch or dent on the vehicle. In many versions, when the driver climbs back in and pulls away, they glance in the rearview mirror and see the same man walking calmly along the road behind them.
Local belief, as reported by Distinctly Montana and The River 97.9, holds that the apparition is the spirit of a Native American man struck and killed along this highway many years ago. Both sources are careful to note that no such fatal accident has been verified in the historical record, and they frame the story as folklore. The legend is reinforced by the setting itself: a dark, fast, featureless prairie highway where a figure can appear and disappear against the night with no witnesses to confirm what was, or was not, there.
Notable Entities
Drive the stretch of US Highway 87 northeast of Great Falls toward Fort Benton, passing the seasonal bed of Black Horse Lake. This is the corridor where motorists report the phantom hitchhiker. There are no stops, tours, or amenities; the route is experienced from the car. Drive carefully and do not pull onto the narrow shoulder.
Every HauntBound history is researched from documented sources. We clearly separate verified historical fact from paranormal folklore.
Griffith, IN
Reeder Road is a former connecting roadway between Griffith and Merrillville in Lake County, Indiana. The county closed the road to vehicle traffic in the 1970s; the right of way remains as wooded land and an informal walking path, with Ross Cemetery anchoring the southern end of the local legend cycle.
Libby, MT
Sportsman's RV Park outside Libby, Montana, occupies the former site of the Riverside Inn, a steak house, gas station, motel, and reportedly a brothel that served construction workers during the late 1960s Libby Dam project. The Inn burned down some years after the dam's completion and was not rebuilt.
Anniston, AL
Camp Cottaquilla was established in 1947 as a permanent residential facility for Girl Scouts of North-Central Alabama. The 1600-acre facility occupies 300 acres in the Whites Gap section of Calhoun County, chosen for its scenic beauty, natural streams, and hardwood forests. The camp continues active operation as a premier Girl Scout camping destination.