HauntBound archive · catalog record
Reported phenomena — as catalogued
A janitor's fatal heart attack in the elevator shaft in the early 1970s left a presence security cameras catch on their own: the elevator moves floors and doors open with no one inside.
1401 Presque Isle Avenue, Marquette, MI 49855
Research updated June 2026
Age
All Ages
Cost
$
Tickets required for performances. Lobby areas accessible to the public during building hours.
Access
Wheelchair OK
University building with accessible entrances on Presque Isle Ave.
Equipment
Photos OK
Est. 1963 · NMU Performing Arts · Upper Peninsula Theater History · Early 1970s Fatality
Forest Roberts Theatre is the main stage venue on Northern Michigan University's Marquette campus, located on Presque Isle Avenue along the southern shore of Lake Superior. The building functions as both an academic training facility for NMU's performing arts programs and a public performance venue for the Upper Peninsula region.
In the early 1970s, a university janitor suffered a fatal heart attack while in the elevator shaft that connects Forest Roberts Theatre to the adjacent arts building. The specific name of the janitor and the exact date of the death are not documented in available sources — the death is reported consistently across regional coverage but without the archival corroboration that would allow attribution by name. The mechanism is consistent and specific: a heart attack in the elevator shaft, not a mechanical accident.
Michigan.org's state tourism platform lists Forest Roberts Theatre among the Upper Peninsula's most haunted locations, citing the janitor's death and the elevator activity as the primary phenomena. The 99.1 WFMK regional radio station, which covers Michigan paranormal topics, also documents the theatre among Marquette-area haunted locations.
The building's role as an active university theatre — with late-night rehearsals, technical crew working after hours, and security monitoring — provides an unusual documentation environment for the elevator reports. Security camera footage of the elevator operating independently has been cited consistently across multiple sources.
Sources
The haunting at Forest Roberts Theatre is specific and mechanically focused. The janitor who died in the elevator shaft in the early 1970s is credited with animating the building's most reported phenomenon: the elevator between the theatre and the arts building operating on its own after hours. Security personnel have reported — and cameras have reportedly captured — the elevator car moving between floors and its doors opening to empty landings with no one present and no call button engaged.
The consistency of this specific report across multiple sources and years is notable. Michigan.org lists the autonomous elevator as the primary phenomenon, and 99.1 WFMK's coverage of Marquette haunted locations documents the same account. The reports are not elaborated with apparition sightings or dramatic encounters — they are narrowly focused on the elevator, which gives them a more credible texture than diffuse multi-phenomenon accounts.
Forest Roberts Theatre's status as a university building means the elevator is used daily, its mechanical state is routinely monitored, and any malfunctions would be flagged for maintenance. The persistence of the autonomous-movement reports in this environment — across successive security staff who presumably arrive without the tradition — is the strongest element of the legend.
Forest Roberts Theatre is Northern Michigan University's main performance venue. Public visitors can access lobby areas and attend ticketed productions. The elevator connecting the theatre to the adjacent arts building is the focus of the paranormal tradition; it is visible from the lobby.
Every HauntBound history is researched from documented sources. We clearly separate verified historical fact from paranormal folklore.
Traverse City, MI
The City Opera House was built in 1891 by three brothers-in-law—James Milliken, James Crawford, and Alexander Hannah—and is one of the few remaining Victorian-era opera houses in Michigan. It has operated continuously as a performance venue for more than 130 years.
Traverse City, MI
Opened July 4, 1916 as the Lyric Theatre, Traverse City's Front Street cinema has burned twice — in 1923 and again in 1948 — before the current structure took its final form. The building has operated continuously as a movie house and event space for over a century.
Columbia, SC
Longstreet Theatre was constructed in 1855 as a chapel and auditorium at the University of South Carolina. During the Civil War, when the university suspended operations, the building was converted into a 300-bed Confederate field hospital with a working morgue in its barrel-vaulted basement. The Department of Theatre and Dance has occupied the building since the 1970s after extensive renovation converted it into a 312-seat arena stage.