HauntBound archive · catalog record
Reported phenomena — as catalogued
+ 2 further entries on record
One of Michigan's most haunted lighthouses with tragic keeper history
Marquette, MI
Research updated May 2026
Age
All Ages
Cost
$$
Overnight stays available; rates vary by season (May-Nov); breakfast included
Access
Wheelchair OK
Rocky bluff, stairs to tower
Equipment
Photos OK
Est. 1896 · Maritime Navigation · Lake Superior Shipping · Upper Peninsula History · Lighthouse Preservation
Big Bay Point Light occupies a five-acre parcel on a rocky bluff approximately 24 miles northwest of Marquette on Michigan's Upper Peninsula. Congress authorized the light station on February 15, 1893, and appropriated $25,000 for construction on August 18, 1894. After acquiring the site in 1895, construction began in May 1896 and was completed the following October.
On October 20, 1896, the lighthouse's 3rd-order fixed Fresnel lens entered service, guiding vessels through the treacherous waters of Lake Superior. The structure was designed and built at a cost of $25,000—equivalent to over $800,000 in modern currency. The lighthouse operated continuously with human keepers until 1944, when the station was automated.
William H. Prior served as the first keeper from 1896 to 1901. Following a pattern of assistant keeper transfers, Prior hired his eldest son George E. Prior in 1900 to assist with station operations. In spring 1901, George suffered a severe fall on the stairs, requiring hospitalization in Marquette. Despite medical intervention, gangrene developed from the wound and George died in June 1901.
Devastated by his son's death, William Prior disappeared into the woods on June 28, 1901, carrying a gun and strychnine. His remains were discovered seventeen months later hanging from a tree approximately 1.5 miles south of the lighthouse station.
The lighthouse transitioned from automated operation to private use, and opened as a Bed & Breakfast inn in the 1980s.
Sources
Big Bay Point Lighthouse carries the weight of a documented family tragedy, and that history is woven through the paranormal phenomena reported there. Guests and innkeepers attribute multiple distinct apparitions and poltergeist-type phenomena to the spirits of Principal Keeper William H. Prior, his son George E. Prior, and additional entities whose identities remain undetermined.
William Prior's apparition is most frequently reported, appearing in the distinctive uniform of a nineteenth-century lighthouse keeper—specifically in a U.S. life-saving service uniform. Multiple independent visitors have independently reported seeing this tall figure moving through the lighthouse grounds and residence areas. His appearance is consistent across reports, suggesting either a genuine residual haunting or a widely shared cultural narrative shaped by the documented history.
Poltergeist-type phenomena attributed to Prior include the repeated opening and slamming of kitchen cupboard doors. Innkeepers and paranormal investigators interpret this activity as an expression of Prior's anguish and unresolved trauma surrounding his son's death and his own suicide. The phenomenon follows a consistent pattern suggestive of RSPK (Recurrent Spontaneous Psychokinesis) activity.
George E. Prior's presence has been reported less frequently than his father's, but visitors describe sensing the emotional weight and trauma associated with his death from complications following his fall.
A striking recurring report describes a small ghost of a girl appearing on the upper floors of the lighthouse, standing and gazing out toward Lake Superior. This apparition appears in full daylight and displays intelligent haunting characteristics—awareness of observers and apparent purposeful activity. Her identity remains mysterious; no documented records explain her presence at the lighthouse.
Additional phenomena include showers turning on autonomously in the basement, loud unexplained banging sounds, lights cycling on and off, doors opening and closing, and audible footsteps with no visible source. Paranormal investigation teams have reported detecting evidence of as many as five distinct spirits within the structure.
The lighthouse remains one of Michigan's most actively reported haunted locations, with consistent visitor accounts spanning decades of operation as a bed and breakfast.
Notable Entities
Media Appearances
Stay overnight at the Big Bay Point Lighthouse Bed & Breakfast, which operates within the historic 1896 lighthouse structure. Guests experience the building where multiple spirits are reported, including the tragic keeper William Prior and his son George.
Tour the 1896 lighthouse tower and keeper's quarters during daylight hours. The site overlooks Lake Superior from a rocky bluff approximately 24 miles northwest of Marquette.
See current room rates and availability at Big Bay Point Lighthouse.
Check rates and bookEvery HauntBound history is researched from documented sources. We clearly separate verified historical fact from paranormal folklore.
Free Guide
10 verified stops, rated for families, mapped in order. Free.
One email to confirm, then the guide link. Unsubscribe anytime.
Mackinac Island, MI
Bogan Lane Inn was built in the mid-1850s during Mackinac Island's transition from fur-trading center to fishing hub and emerging tourist destination. The structure represents residential architecture from an era when the island was rapidly developing economically and socially.
.jpg)
Mackinac Island, MI
The Mackinac Island Hotel Company — backed by two railroads and a Great Lakes steamship line — built the Grand Hotel in just 93 days, opening it on July 10, 1887, as a summer resort reached by boat and rail. Designed by the Detroit firm Mason & Rice in the Queen Anne style, it's known for a 660-foot front porch, among the longest of any hotel in the world. It became a Michigan State Historic Site in 1957, joined the National Register of Historic Places in 1972, and was designated a National Historic Landmark in 1989. Five U.S. presidents and figures including Mark Twain and Thomas Edison have stayed there. One family ran the hotel for nearly nine decades before selling it to KSL Capital Partners in 2019.
Arcadia, MO
Arcadia Academy was founded in 1846 by Methodist circuit rider Jerome C. Berryman as a high school in Arcadia, Missouri, in the Iron County Ozarks. The campus served as a Union hospital during the Civil War (1861-1863). In 1877 the Ursuline Order purchased the property for $30,000 and operated it as a girls' school until the final graduating class in 1971. The nuns continued to run a daycare on site until 1991, when they held a public auction and relocated to St. Louis. The campus is now under private family ownership, listed on the National Register of Historic Places, and operates as a bed-and-breakfast retaining its 19th-century structures.