HauntBound archive · catalog record
Reported phenomena, as catalogued
A Barnstable Village tavern where 'Lucy' is said to linger over an underground stream
3176 Main Street (Route 6A), Barnstable, MA 02630
Research updated June 2026
Age
All Ages
Cost
$$
Operating restaurant and bar; menu pricing applies. No cover charge to dine.
Access
Wheelchair OK
Village storefront on Route 6A with paved access
Equipment
Photos OK
Barnstable Village Historic Streetscape · Old King's Highway Corridor · Cape Cod Folklore
The Barnstable Restaurant and Tavern sits on Main Street, Route 6A, in the heart of Barnstable Village, part of the Old King's Highway corridor that runs through some of Cape Cod's oldest standing buildings. The 1716 Barnstable House, the 1690 Old Gaol, and the 1763 Olde Colonial Courthouse all stand within a short walk.
Local accounts collected by Cape Cod LIFE and regional travel writers describe the tavern as carrying a piece of the village's most enduring ghost story. The legend centers on Lucy Paine, a child said to have drowned in an underground stream that runs beneath the nearby Barnstable House. After a fire at the Barnstable House, some tellings hold that activity associated with Lucy shifted to the tavern.
The restaurant is a working establishment and a fixture of the village dining scene. It is also a recurring reference point on the Barnstable Village Haunted History Tour, which since 2001 has guided visitors past the village's historic and reputedly haunted addresses.
Sources
The legend the tavern is best known for belongs first to its neighbor, the 1716 Barnstable House, where Lucy Paine is said to have drowned after falling into the entrance of an underground river that passes beneath the building. Local tellings hold that after a fire at the Barnstable House, some of the activity associated with Lucy moved to the nearby tavern.
Staff at the restaurant have described a series of small, mischievous incidents, the kind of misplaced-objects and minor-prank phenomena that tend to attach to a child's spirit in folklore. Cape Cod LIFE's coverage of the village tours notes the tavern's paranormal associations alongside the better-documented Barnstable House story.
The Barnstable Village Haunted History Tour, run by the Cape and Islands Paranormal Research Society, passes the building as part of its walk through the village. For visitors, the tavern offers a low-key way to take in the lore: a meal in a working Route 6A restaurant whose story is tied to the village's most repeated ghost.
Notable Entities
Sit down for a meal at the working restaurant and tavern on Route 6A in Barnstable Village, the building local lore connects to the spirit of the child known as Lucy. The Barnstable Village Haunted History Tour passes the building seasonally and recounts the story.
Some links on this page may earn HauntBound a small commission when you book, at no extra cost to you. Our editorial picks are independent. Full disclosure
Every HauntBound history is researched from documented sources. We clearly separate verified historical fact from paranormal folklore.
Free Guide
11 verified stops, rated for families, mapped in order. Free.
One email to confirm, then the guide link. Unsubscribe anytime.
Mystic, CT
Captain Daniel Packer bought the land bordering Water Street in Mystic in 1754 and finished building his house in 1756. Packer ran a rope ferry across the Mystic River and entertained travelers between New York and Boston who stopped for the night. The house stayed with Packer's family and their descendants, the Keelers, until the late 1970s, when new owners restored it as a restaurant and pub.
Virginia City, MT
The Bale of Hay Saloon occupies one of Virginia City's oldest buildings, reported by Southwest Montana as dating to 1863, and is often called Montana's oldest bar. The official operator history identifies the J.F. Stoer Saloon, run by Henry Schwenk, from 1869 to 1890, followed by Smith and Boyd in the 1890s, who named it for the hay bales stacked outside for horses at the neighboring stable.
Cape Girardeau, MO
Katy O'Ferrell's occupies 300 Broadway in downtown Cape Girardeau, a building whose core dates to an 1806 structure built by Charles Ellis. The Turner Society demolished most of that building in 1868-1888, keeping only the rear sandstone foundation, and the Masons later ran it as the Opera House and Masonic Lodge from 1881 to 1891. A fire on March 8, 1990 destroyed the building's upper two floors, which were rebuilt before Katy O'Ferrell's opened in 2014. The second floor is closed to regular use, and staff associate it with unexplained activity.