43-Room Coal Baron Estate Turned Catholic School
405 Third Street, Paintsville, KY 41240
Research updated May 2026
Age
All Ages
Cost
Free
Tours available by appointment; contact Our Lady of the Mountains School
Access
Wheelchair OK
Paved, flat
Equipment
Photos OK
Est. 1912 · National Register of Historic Places · Coal Era Architecture · Appalachian Economic History · Catholic Education History
Ground was broken for Mayo Mansion in 1905, and construction continued for seven years before the 43-room, three-story residence was completed in December 1912. The cost was $250,000 — equivalent to over $8 million in 2024 dollars — making it among the most expensive private residences ever built in eastern Kentucky.
John Caldwell Calhoun Mayo had accumulated his fortune through a methodical campaign of purchasing coal mineral rights from Appalachian landowners before the railroads arrived. As the railroads extended into the region, those rights became enormously valuable, and Mayo became Kentucky's first coal baron. He built the mansion for his wife, Alice Jane Meek, at a time when Paintsville was transforming from a county seat into a regional economic hub.
Mayo died on May 11, 1914, at age 49, less than two years after the mansion's completion. Alice and the couple's two children subsequently moved to Ashland, Kentucky. She donated the mansion and property to Sandy Valley Seminary, administered by the Methodist Episcopal Church South, which established John C.C. Mayo College on the grounds. Later legal disputes arose when Alice attempted to reclaim the property.
In 1945, the property passed to the Catholic Diocese. The Most Reverend William T. Mulloy, Roman Catholic Bishop of Covington, purchased it, and the Sisters of Divine Providence from Melbourne, Kentucky, established Our Lady of the Mountains School in October of that year. The school continues to operate under the sponsorship of the Catholic Diocese of Lexington.
The mansion is listed on the National Register of Historic Places. A connected underground tunnel running from the mansion to the nearby Mayo Memorial United Methodist Church — built simultaneously as a companion project — has long been filled in.
Sources
Two distinct figures inhabit the folklore around Mayo Mansion and its grounds.
The first is John Mayo himself, reported on the sidewalk in front of the property — standing in era-appropriate clothing and hat, watching cars pass. The detail of period dress is consistent across the accounts, which is unusual in casual folklore, suggesting the description either originates from a single credible witness or has been retold so many times the specifics have calcified. The figure does not interact with observers.
The second figure is a woman seen inside the building — kneeling in prayer, or simply sitting in one of the rooms. Most accounts, including those compiled by regional paranormal researchers, identify this figure as Alice Mayo. Alice donated the mansion after John's death, later sued to reclaim it, and ultimately spent the remainder of her life in Ashland, where she died September 5, 1961. Whether the tradition of an interior female presence overlaps with, or developed independently from, similar reports at the nearby Mayo Memorial United Methodist Church is unclear.
A third element in the folklore involves the tunnel. During construction of both the mansion and the church, Mayo built an underground passage connecting the two buildings. The tunnel has been filled for decades. Standing near the site of the sealed entrance, according to accounts in the Shadowlands Haunted Places Index, produces an unsettling sensation not fully explained by the physical surroundings. This report is vaguer than the apparition accounts and harder to evaluate.
Because the building is an active Catholic school, access is restricted to appointment-based tours during school calendar windows.
Notable Entities
A guided walk through the 43-room, three-story mansion completed in 1912 for Kentucky's first coal baron at a cost of $250,000. The mansion now houses Our Lady of the Mountains Catholic School and is accessible by appointment. The sidewalk in front — where the apparition of John Mayo is reportedly seen in period dress — is publicly accessible.
The exterior facade and surrounding sidewalk are publicly accessible. Local tradition holds that the figure of John C.C. Mayo, dressed in period clothing and hat, has been observed standing on the sidewalk watching passing traffic.
Every HauntBound history is researched from documented sources. We clearly separate verified historical fact from paranormal folklore.
New London, CT
Built in 1909 at the mouth of the Thames River, New London Ledge Lighthouse is a three-story brick structure designed in a French Second Empire style to complement the elegant coastal homes of New London. It served Long Island Sound shipping until automation in 1987 and now operates as a museum under the New London Maritime Society.
Chicago, IL
Robert C. Givins, a Chicago real estate developer, built the limestone Beverly Castle between 1886 and 1887 as his personal residence. It is Chicago's last standing castle and is listed on the National Register of Historic Places. The Beverly Unitarian Church purchased the building in 1942 and continues to occupy it today.
Muskegon, MI
USS LST-393 is one of only two surviving LSTs from World War II still accessible to the public. Built in 1942 and commissioned in 1943, she participated in the invasion of Sicily, the Normandy landings on D-Day, and operations in the Pacific before being decommissioned and eventually converted to a Great Lakes ferry. Saved from scrapping in 2000, she has been a museum ship on Muskegon Lake since 2005.