Aerial survey · USDA NAIP · public domainWhere eleven people died in Ashland's deadliest fire on Valentine's Day 1959, including a family of six trapped in a former theater converted to apartments
Greenup Avenue, Ashland, KY 41101
Research updated June 2026
Age
All Ages
Cost
Free
Public sidewalk; no admission fee. Site is best visited as part of the Ashland Haunted History Ghost Tour.
Access
Wheelchair OK
Downtown Ashland sidewalks; flat and paved.
Equipment
Photos OK
Est. 1891 · Deadliest Fire in Ashland History · 1959 Valentine's Day Disaster
The building at Greenup Avenue in Ashland began its life as the Columbia Theater, constructed in 1891. By 1959 it had been converted to apartments with a restaurant and a sign painting shop occupying the first floor. The structure was old enough to predate modern fire codes, and its conversion left it with a single exit: a front stairway.
In the early hours of Valentine's Day, February 14, 1959, a gas worker had removed and repaired a stove on the second floor but failed to shut off the gas supply when the stove was removed. At approximately 1:00 a.m., gas that had accumulated in the building ignited, triggering a fire that spread rapidly through the wood-framed structure.
The single stairway, the building's only path out, was immediately engulfed. Residents on upper floors had no alternative escape route. The McKenzie family — Jack McKenzie, 30; his wife Polly, 28 and eight months pregnant; and their three sons aged one, two, and four — were in an interior apartment with no windows. All six died. Polly McKenzie jumped from a window before reaching the hospital; she delivered a stillborn child and died shortly after. The total death count was eleven: seven adults and four children.
Ironically, materials for a fire escape had been delivered and were sitting in the rear yard, scheduled for installation the following week. Ashland police officers on the scene helped residents leap from second-floor windows.
Local historians and ghost tour operators have called the Columbia Theater fire the deadliest single building fire in Ashland's history. The Daily Independent covered the story as one of the city's defining tragedies, and the site became an 'Ashland Tragedy' anchor point on subsequent dark-history tour routes.
Sources
The 1959 Columbia Theater fire site appears in Ashland's organized ghost-tour itinerary not because of a specific haunting legend with named apparitions, but because the event itself — eleven dead, including four children, on Valentine's Day — is historically documented and locally resonant.
The Daily Independent's 2014 coverage of the Ashland ghost tour identified this site as one of the stops, grouping it with the 1881 'Ashland Tragedy' (a triple murder and rape) as anchor points for the tour's dark-history narrative. The framing in ghost-tour tradition positions the fire's scale and circumstances — the trapped family, the missing fire escape, the single exit — as generating the kind of residual energy that dark-tourism audiences associate with haunted sites.
No specific apparition, EVP recording, or physical phenomenon has been widely attributed to the Greenup Avenue site in the paranormal literature. The site is best understood as a dark-history marker rather than an active paranormal investigation destination.
The former Columbia Theater building site on Greenup Avenue is a featured stop on the Ashland Haunted History Ghost Tour. Visitors can view the site from the public sidewalk; the story of the 1959 Valentine's Day fire is one of the anchor points of the tour's dark-history narrative.
Every HauntBound history is researched from documented sources. We clearly separate verified historical fact from paranormal folklore.
Aerial survey · USDA NAIPPort St. Lucie, FL
Oak Hammock Park is a Port St. Lucie city park along the C-24 Canal containing a southern live oak associated with the 1972 murders of Collette Goodenough and Barbara Ann Wilcox by Gerard John Schaefer, a former Martin County deputy sheriff. The girls' remains were discovered at the site in January 1977. Schaefer was convicted of two earlier murders in 1973 and killed in prison in 1995.
Aerial survey · USDA NAIPHarrodsburg, KY
The building at 101 W Broadway in Harrodsburg dates to 1843, constructed as the Benjamin Passmore Hotel — a substantial structure in what was then Kentucky's oldest permanent settlement. Later known as Mercer House, the building eventually became home to the Harrodsburg Herald, the local newspaper.
Aerial survey · USDA NAIPHarlan, KY
The building at 108 N. Main Street in downtown Harlan previously served as a hardware store with a funeral parlor operating on the upper floors—a combination common in early 20th-century Appalachian commercial buildings. It is now featured on the Kentucky After Dark dark-history trail.