HauntBound archive · catalog record
Reported phenomena, as catalogued
+ 3 further entries on record
1858 Italianate mansion on Indianapolis's south side
3801 Madison Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46227
Research updated September 2026
Age
Open House tours all ages; paranormal investigations 18+
Cost
$$
Open House history tour: $10 adults, free for children 12 and under, first Sunday of the month 1-4 pm. Private history tours: $25/person. Paranormal investigations: $750 base for 10 people, $75 each additional, $100/hour beyond contracted time, $250 deposit.
Access
Limited Access
Multi-floor 1858 mansion with original staircases and uneven flooring
Equipment
Photos OK
Est. 1858 · California Gold Rush · Italianate Architecture · National Register of Historic Places · 19th-Century Indianapolis · Antebellum Architecture · Indianapolis History
Alexander Moore Hannah was born in Wayne County, Indiana, and trained as a harness maker before joining the migration to California during the Gold Rush. He returned to Indiana with substantial capital and, in 1858, purchased either 240 or 300 acres, depending on the source, on what was then the rural south edge of Indianapolis from his father, Samuel Hannah. He built a three-story brick Italianate house on the property, with a center-hall plan, full basement, and outbuildings supporting a working farm.
Hannah also served in the Indiana General Assembly. In 1872 he married Elizabeth Jackson. The couple had no surviving children. Elizabeth died in 1888 and Alexander in 1895, and in 1899 the house was sold to Roman Oehler, whose family held it for decades in the 20th century. The Indianapolis Recorder and the Encyclopedia of Indianapolis both call the popular folklore connecting Hannah to the Underground Railroad an urban myth with no documentary evidence; it emerged in 20th-century retellings rather than from period sources.
The property is now operated as a historic site and event venue. The mansion is open for guided history tours on the first Sunday of each month, with private tours by appointment and overnight paranormal investigations available for groups. The house was added to the National Register of Historic Places in 1978.
Sources
Reports of activity at Hannah House began surfacing during the 1960s and 1970s, when the property was rented as a private residence. Tenants described unexplained noises overhead, lights and appliances cycling on without input, and small objects relocating between rooms. These accounts predate the house's current operation as a public site.
The basement is the most-cited area in current paranormal programming — the room is associated with the Underground Railroad story that the Indianapolis Recorder and the Encyclopedia of Indianapolis call an unsubstantiated urban myth. Investigators have reported cold spots, unaccountable footsteps, and recordings of voices on digital recorders. The first-floor parlor and the second-floor bedrooms are also frequently mentioned in trip reports posted by visiting groups; activity in upstairs rooms is sometimes described informally as a female presence, though no operator-published source identifies the figure by name.
The Indianapolis Recorder, in its profile of the property, treats the haunting reputation as a layered cultural artifact alongside the contested Underground Railroad folklore. The current operators schedule overnight investigations from 9 pm to 5 am with bring-your-own equipment, allowing groups of up to ten investigators to document their own experiences, and aggregating submitted findings into the property's archive.
A monthly daytime guided tour of the 1858 Hannah House, including the parlor, dining room, and the basement room associated with the property's most-cited folklore. $10 for adults, free for children 12 and under.
Scheduled private daytime tour of the mansion at $25 per person, by appointment.
An overnight investigation from 9 pm to 5 am with full access to the mansion's three floors and basement. Base rate $750 for ten investigators, $75 each additional. Bring your own equipment.
Private rental of the 1858 Hannah House for events, available until 11 PM with a four-hour minimum.
Some links on this page may earn HauntBound a small commission when you book, at no extra cost to you. Our editorial picks are independent. Full disclosure
Every HauntBound history is researched from documented sources. We clearly separate verified historical fact from paranormal folklore.
Free Guide
11 verified stops, rated for families, mapped in order. Free.
One email to confirm, then the guide link. Unsubscribe anytime.
Atlanta, GA
Rhodes Hall was built 1902-1904 for furniture magnate Amos Giles Rhodes, founder of Rhodes Furniture. Designed by Atlanta architect Willis F. Denny II of Stone Mountain granite in a Romanesque Revival style with Victorian and Arts and Crafts interior elements. Listed on the National Register of Historic Places in 1974; Atlanta Landmark Building since 1989; headquarters of the Georgia Trust for Historic Preservation since 1983.
Charles City, VA
Benjamin Harrison IV built the current mansion at Berkeley Plantation in 1726, making it one of the oldest three-story brick houses in Virginia. The plantation became the birthplace of President William Henry Harrison in 1773 and the ancestral seat of a family that produced a signer of the Declaration of Independence and two U.S. Presidents. During the Civil War, General McClellan used the mansion as his headquarters and the cellar held Confederate prisoners.
Macon, GA
Built between 1855 and 1859 for businessman William Butler Johnston at a cost of approximately $100,000, the Italian Renaissance Revival mansion at 934 Georgia Avenue has been called the 'Palace of the South' and is a National Historic Landmark. The house remained in Johnston hands through the Civil War, spared when Sherman's march to the sea bypassed Macon; it passed to the Johnstons' daughter Mary Ellen and her husband, Judge William Felton, in 1896. The Hay family acquired the house in 1926 and donated it to The Georgia Trust for Historic Preservation in 1977.