Boon Hutch Cemetery has accumulated significant paranormal folklore documented by multiple paranormal research teams and paranormal enthusiasts. The site is reported to host multiple categories of paranormal phenomena.
One of the most distinctive paranormal reports involves the apparition of a 1950s police officer who reportedly sits or stands within the cemetery grounds. This apparition is associated with a blue light phenomenon, described as an unexplained light source accompanying the officer's presence. The specific historical context for the police officer's death or reason for haunting remains undocumented.
Paranormal investigators report encountering phantom dogs described as "evil looking" and "sinister" in appearance. These apparitions are characterized by black coloration and red glowing eyes. The phantom dogs allegedly chase paranormal investigators and visitors away from the cemetery grounds, pursuing them to their vehicles before vanishing. Witnesses describe these encounters as threatening despite the dogs' inability to cause physical contact.
The cave system within the cemetery is a focal point for paranormal activity. Visitors report seeing strange figures standing in the cave entrance and within the cave chamber. Some accounts describe unusual shapes or forms that defy clear identification. One particularly disturbing narrative involves reports that bodies fall out of their caskets into the cave system, suggesting either disturbance of remains or manifestations of paranormal phenomena.
Paranormal investigators conducting 3am investigations have documented what they interpret as spirit communication. According to accounts, the spirits began talking and warning investigators about a "scary shadow" that lurks in surrounding woods. Investigators report constant sensations of being watched, heavy emotional atmospheres, and the sound of footsteps walking on the gravel paths when no physical people are present.
The convergence of multiple paranormal phenomena—apparitions, phantom animals, underground cave systems, and documented voice communication—has made Boon Hutch Cemetery popular among paranormal investigation communities.